📖 Grimepedia
An archive of grimeforum.com, 2007–2022. Read-only.
Archive › Grime Discussion

Why was garage more successful mainstream wise?

8th May '10, 03:59 PM#1
iKlozzleGrime Forum RegularJoined: September 2009Posts: 6,991▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
It seems garage seemed to achieve more commercial success than grime ever has, just wondered why you might think this was...

Because not all grime is "violent" and "offensive", I mean you look at tracks like Go Rapid and Sidetracked etc, why can't these chart?

Why must grime artists produce watered down tracks to achieve mainstream success?
M.O.G. said:
Now please, enjoy your 'Manchester United' thread and stop mentioning Liverpool so much, were not rivals.
Thanks for confirming bro
8th May '10, 04:00 PM#2
InsanityYour Posts Sound Out Of Date And Expired I Check My CP, Got Bare AdmiresJoined: December 2009Posts: 4,934▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
hmmm another 1 of these threads.........


ZZZZZZZzzzzzZZZZZZzzzzz
8th May '10, 04:01 PM#3
adidasgrandadGrime Forum OGiDonateJoined: January 2008Posts: 18,968▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
garage had the women dancing to it though. brilliant club music as well.
smokey joe - "Mik looks likes a turtle"
8th May '10, 04:05 PM#4
Sonic The HedgehogPosts: 624Since: 2010
Garage >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

- CDs actually come out on time
- Theres no clashes for mcs to duck out of
- Radio DJ's are good at mixing
8th May '10, 04:06 PM#5
Matt91Grime Forum OGiDonateJoined: February 2008Posts: 24,765▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Because it was one of the best genres of music I've heard, plus it attracted plenty of women, was dancey and bubbley and went off inna club
habits & contradictions
8th May '10, 04:07 PM#6
BlimeyMy Fingers Type Like They're Powered MechanicallyJoined: January 2008Reppin: www.Blimeyworld.netPosts: 2,835▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
adidasgrandad said:
garage had the women dancing to it though. brilliant club music as well.
^. This is why we need mainstream music from Roll Deep and co.
"In it for the music, not the money"
https://www.PromoSpot.co.uk- Soooo much freeness!!!
https://www.Blimeyworld.net/Wiley- Wiley artist profile: downloads, videos & releases.
https://www.Grimetube.Tv - The Grime Music Channel
https://www.Blimeyworld.net/TheLink - TheLink to the grime scenes finest.
8th May '10, 04:10 PM#7
InsanityYour Posts Sound Out Of Date And Expired I Check My CP, Got Bare AdmiresJoined: December 2009Posts: 4,934▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Blimey said:
^. This is why we need mainstream music from Roll Deep and co.
smh
8th May '10, 04:10 PM#8
critic of musical arts...Joined: January 2008Reppin: NewhamPosts: 22,553▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
because its not as aggressive. (beats and bars wise)
I'm not talking about them 1 on 1 swingers, i'm talking bout kidnapping man in a dingers, put the gat to your head and ask if its on, if he says yes then PAT PAT gone!
8th May '10, 04:13 PM#9
adidasgrandadGrime Forum OGiDonateJoined: January 2008Posts: 18,968▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Blimey said:
^. This is why we need mainstream music from Roll Deep and co.
nah i dont believe that. that music is straight up pop the only thing associating it with grime is the artist.

grime is sick club music but there just isnt enough of that aspect of the music being released. next hype goes off everywhere iv been. need more of the energetic, catchy stuff to go nuts and singalong to.
smokey joe - "Mik looks likes a turtle"
8th May '10, 04:14 PM#10
RandyBSciDonateJoined: January 2008Reppin: E14Posts: 5,390▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
because everyone liked it. sat at a good place between dance and urban.
You are invited to join my private poker club for Home Games online.
- If you don't already have it, download the free PokerStars software from www.pokerstars.com
- Open the main poker lobby, then click on the Home Games tab
- Click the 'Join a Poker Club' button - Enter my Club ID number: 461645 - Enter my Invitation Code: anditstee
8th May '10, 04:16 PM#11
InsanityYour Posts Sound Out Of Date And Expired I Check My CP, Got Bare AdmiresJoined: December 2009Posts: 4,934▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
if girls can't relate/dance to it

its not gonna be successful in mainstream


/thread
8th May '10, 04:19 PM#12
BlimeyMy Fingers Type Like They're Powered MechanicallyJoined: January 2008Reppin: www.Blimeyworld.netPosts: 2,835▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
adidasgrandad said:
nah i dont believe that. that music is straight up pop the only thing associating it with grime is the artist.

grime is sick club music but there just isnt enough of that aspect of the music being released. next hype goes off everywhere iv been. need more of the energetic, catchy stuff to go nuts and singalong to.
But when ive heard it in the clubs i never see the girls enjoying it, theyve been dropping I Luv U along side it aswell and that gets a simmilar response.
"In it for the music, not the money"
https://www.PromoSpot.co.uk- Soooo much freeness!!!
https://www.Blimeyworld.net/Wiley- Wiley artist profile: downloads, videos & releases.
https://www.Grimetube.Tv - The Grime Music Channel
https://www.Blimeyworld.net/TheLink - TheLink to the grime scenes finest.
8th May '10, 04:26 PM#13
iKlozzleGrime Forum RegularJoined: September 2009Posts: 6,991▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
adidasgrandad said:
nah i dont believe that. that music is straight up pop the only thing associating it with grime is the artist.

grime is sick club music but there just isnt enough of that aspect of the music being released. next hype goes off everywhere iv been. need more of the energetic, catchy stuff to go nuts and singalong to.
I agree mate, some grime instrumentals are sick and would tear down any club. Good Times is pop, not grime. Where as pure garage was actually commercially successful.

I can't see why P Money isn't a marketable prospect, he produces grime bangers, that would tear up the club scene.
M.O.G. said:
Now please, enjoy your 'Manchester United' thread and stop mentioning Liverpool so much, were not rivals.
Thanks for confirming bro
8th May '10, 04:30 PM#14
InsanityYour Posts Sound Out Of Date And Expired I Check My CP, Got Bare AdmiresJoined: December 2009Posts: 4,934▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
watered down grime<<<<<<<<<<<<<<

p money/tempa t tracks etc do well in clubs........not charts tho
8th May '10, 04:31 PM#15
redtshirtPosts: 288Since: 2010
less talk about guns drugs and shanks.... it still existed but as i said. less.
8th May '10, 04:32 PM#16
316Grime Forum OGJoined: October 2009Reppin: over therePosts: 20,627▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
i was gonna post the 'i bring u flowers' video

but now im gonna watch the 'sweet like chocolate' video instead
8th May '10, 04:33 PM#17
LogikI Ain't One Of Those Posters That You Wanna Go AgainstJoined: March 2009Reppin: BristolPosts: 1,774▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Appealed to women
/thread
Killing off cops ain't a ting that'll shock me
Donut eating pricks make me sick, cuz they're stocky
Hot pucks hitting head tops, like it's hockey
Jawside hits the floor, like it's rocky
8th May '10, 04:40 PM#18
adidasgrandadGrime Forum OGiDonateJoined: January 2008Posts: 18,968▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Insanity said:
watered down grime<<<<<<<<<<<<<<

p money/tempa t tracks etc do well in clubs........not charts tho
you can make a healthy living off a club hit though. tempz got loads of bookings off next hype, boy off the ting and even 'swing'. p money made loads of bookings of both the sukh night tracks hes done.
smokey joe - "Mik looks likes a turtle"
8th May '10, 04:45 PM#19
The ElijahBUTTERZ IS THE LABELiSupportReppin: Rinse FMPosts: 9,554▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Have to remember this was 10 years ago when people used to make money selling music. Whole different ball game now
8th May '10, 04:46 PM#20
FGja ja soze if you change ur american accent i will listen to you otherwise i cant hear ya realest talk from wileyiDonateJoined: January 2008Reppin: South LondonPosts: 6,667▮▮▮▮▮▮
Matt91 said:
Because it was one of the best genres of music I've heard, plus it attracted plenty of women, was dancey and bubbley and went off inna club
Grime is much more insular as well, content that the average Joe can't relate to and which probably alienates most.

I think around them times though that garage was successful mainstream-wise because that kinda sound was more in vogue - just the times and these things tend to be cyclical.

You could maybe say that the kinda pop/urban whatever you wanna call it stuff is in a similar situation now
"Trust me London, about Real Deep. Where you going with Real Deep? You know what yeah can I say one thing London? I wanna say one thing. Roll Deep - Real Deep. Just check that out, check that out. Did he even try hard to start a new crew and start a new name? I know I'm carrying going on yeah but I'm not having it blud, I'm not having it. Hold tight Jamakabi, I'm not having it, I'm slewing you I said that."
8th May '10, 04:47 PM#21
RandyBSciDonateJoined: January 2008Reppin: E14Posts: 5,390▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
so solid werent massively appealing to women really. well their music wasnt. was more of a right timing thing with chavs etc being in.
You are invited to join my private poker club for Home Games online.
- If you don't already have it, download the free PokerStars software from www.pokerstars.com
- Open the main poker lobby, then click on the Home Games tab
- Click the 'Join a Poker Club' button - Enter my Club ID number: 461645 - Enter my Invitation Code: anditstee
8th May '10, 04:48 PM#22
grimeisopensourceSoundbwoy MurdererJoined: August 2009Posts: 2,650▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
girls
8th May '10, 04:50 PM#23
iKlozzleGrime Forum RegularJoined: September 2009Posts: 6,991▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
What about the more raw grime artists though like Ghetto (not Ghetts LOLz) who are about big bars and not exactly singalongs? I mean he's been successful, but then again, I guess he released shit like top 3 selected, sing for me and shit.
M.O.G. said:
Now please, enjoy your 'Manchester United' thread and stop mentioning Liverpool so much, were not rivals.
Thanks for confirming bro
8th May '10, 04:54 PM#24
DazIt Don't Make Sense To Me Shit Posters Wanna Send For MeJoined: April 2009Posts: 2,403▮
no greeze
8th May '10, 05:06 PM#25
NocturnalNite Knights Productions - Fucking Badman ProducerJoined: June 2008Posts: 32▮
The garage scene was'nt based on egocentric personalities. The focus was the music/vibes/club scene.

Where as the grime scene has been pushed out of the clubs and mainly exists online or in/on computers. e.g..Youtube channels, download links, files on computers and forums..
8th May '10, 05:33 PM#26
SwitchThey Couldn't Test My Posting On A LevelJoined: December 2008Reppin: NottsPosts: 397▮
Insanity said:
if girls can't relate/dance to it

its not gonna be successful in mainstream
/thread.
"But that's how it is when you dealin with the evil
Get a little status and they think you too regal
That's the nature of people
Why you think muh'fuckers like to feed pigeons but try to shoot eagles?" - Phonte-Can't Let Her
8th May '10, 05:34 PM#27
Boris BowserGrime Forum EliteJoined: January 2010Posts: 11,090▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Matt91 said:
Because it was one of the best genres of music I've heard, plus it attracted plenty of women, was dancey and bubbley and went off inna club
.

Although the new style of Garage is largely shit
Rachetmusic said:
inbox me ur number if wanna talk and explain ur side off the story if u think u have the balls 2 talk 2 me and tell me why u have blocked me out all these years be a man and stand up 2 ur fears or be a woman with long hair and chat shit.
8th May '10, 05:35 PM#28
RetrofreakSuper ModRadio is dead... Music lives on in the minds of the free!!Posts: 13,831▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Melody+chics
The Victorious Warrior First Wins Then Seeks Battle
The Defeated Warrior First Battles Then Seeks Victory
- Sun Tzu
8th May '10, 05:35 PM#29
Boris BowserGrime Forum EliteJoined: January 2010Posts: 11,090▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Nocturnal said:
The garage scene was'nt based on egocentric personalities. The focus was the music/vibes/club scene.

Where as the grime scene has been pushed out of the clubs and mainly exists online or in/on computers. e.g..Youtube channels, download links, files on computers and forums..
True

Grime with a Garage structure >>> (*hint*)
Rachetmusic said:
inbox me ur number if wanna talk and explain ur side off the story if u think u have the balls 2 talk 2 me and tell me why u have blocked me out all these years be a man and stand up 2 ur fears or be a woman with long hair and chat shit.
8th May '10, 05:38 PM#30
TrueGrimeManMy Fingers Type Like They're Powered MechanicallyJoined: September 2009Posts: 2,981▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
huSaMO4v11s
Even Muslims act fake, I can smell the bacon.
8th May '10, 05:41 PM#31
316Grime Forum OGJoined: October 2009Reppin: over therePosts: 20,627▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
TrueGrimeMan said:
huSaMO4v11s
↪ Garage Appreciation Thread
8th May '10, 06:03 PM#32
Matt91Grime Forum OGiDonateJoined: February 2008Posts: 24,765▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
jn5klRzozig
>>>>

Also the internet wasn't involved as much obviously garage tracks got bootlegged but it wasn't a big as a problem as it is now, not many people knew or cared how to download music early late 90's early 00's
habits & contradictions
8th May '10, 06:29 PM#33
adidasgrandadGrime Forum OGiDonateJoined: January 2008Posts: 18,968▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Nocturnal said:
The garage scene was'nt based on egocentric personalities. The focus was the music/vibes/club scene.

Where as the grime scene has been pushed out of the clubs and mainly exists online or in/on computers. e.g..Youtube channels, download links, files on computers and forums..
the egocentric personalities are one of the main reasons any grime even sells. hype and war = sales.

thats not the reason grime isnt very successful. along with not enough ckub tracks its because the people in grime dont get their music out there quick enough or even promote it effectively. a westwood appearance and a logan sama appearance does not = effective promotion. why should people take note of a music that doesnt sell. and it doesnt sell because you dont promote it effectively to enough people.
smokey joe - "Mik looks likes a turtle"
8th May '10, 06:35 PM#34
RandyBSciDonateJoined: January 2008Reppin: E14Posts: 5,390▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
garage is begging for a proper revival. if i dont get a job i may have to start a record label and push it.
You are invited to join my private poker club for Home Games online.
- If you don't already have it, download the free PokerStars software from www.pokerstars.com
- Open the main poker lobby, then click on the Home Games tab
- Click the 'Join a Poker Club' button - Enter my Club ID number: 461645 - Enter my Invitation Code: anditstee
8th May '10, 07:04 PM#35
+observer+Posts: 239Since: 2010
Most people I know growing up only really listened to tape packs. Everyone was a garage dj though, and actually used to buy their tunes, not sure how big that market actually was though.

Garage music was party music and girls liked it, girls never really took to grime in big numbers.

Rip groove double 99 >>>>>>>
8th May '10, 07:08 PM#36
tazbombermanI Was Like You Rudeboy I Had No Rep To GiiiiivveJoined: June 2009Posts: 1,259▮▮▮▮
its more bubbly and club friendly . like someone else said , it makes the girls move . sing-a-long music sells
8th May '10, 07:12 PM#37
+observer+Posts: 239Since: 2010
girls can dance sexily to garage,

its hard to pull with a bassface and a middle class gun finger
8th May '10, 07:21 PM#38
Sonic The HedgehogPosts: 624Since: 2010
+observer+ said:
Most people I know growing up only really listened to tape packs. Everyone was a garage dj though, and actually used to buy their tunes, not sure how big that market actually was though.

Garage music was party music and girls liked it, girls never really took to grime in big numbers.

Rip groove double 99 >>>>>>>
That tune is a banger.

Old Skool Garage >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
8th May '10, 07:22 PM#39
PredSuper ModThe nation's favourite modJoined: January 2008Reppin: BasingstokePosts: 12,309▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Unanimous decision...a rarity on GrimeForum.

UK Garage was essentially RnB over dance (thinking commercially, not the underground stuff). Singing sells more than rapping, and positivity sells more than negativity. People want to enjoy their free time, and any sort of dance music helps with that.
http://mypsn.eu.playstation.com/psn/profile/BigPred.png
(Might have to refresh it)
I don't care what she likes, man can't say I'm not top 10 in England, bury anybody disagreeing in an instant, stageshow duppy or sunday Rinse them!

See the saved original on the Wayback Machine