The future of England's National team3rd March '11, 01:07 PM
This has turned into a long-winded discussion when really I was just putting across my opinion, which I thought was a very simple point.
In answer though:
Ozil had played first team football for four season before the World Cup, Muller played 34 times for Bayern in the 2009/10 season and had made quite a few appearances in a next league, Khedira had made nearly 100 appearances for Stuttgart.
In addition, Kaka had 40-odd games for Sao Paolo before a cameo against Bolivia for his Brazil debut.
Pele is one of the greatest - all three you mention are great players. Using these as examples, when my original point was only about Capello not immediately picking some promising youngsters - who are not this level and never will be - just all seems a bit ridiculous.
In answer though:
Zoffie said:Never said it should absolutely be the rule either. 'They should be playing...' I also realise that looking solely at the individual is pointless when football is a team game and the collective is - and always will be - the most important aspect. Hence, 'in some cases', youngsters with very limited club experience may be drafted in at international level.
You say in some cases though, which is my point, I haven't said it should be the rule.
My point is, if you know a player & what he can do & you trust the player, call him up, regardless of age, regardless, of match time, regardless of form.
Zoffie said:Wasn't talking about Walcott. Stunting growth is also about career longevity and long-term management, not just immediate set-backs from playing at a young age which is not that likely in comparison.
You have to give examples of stunting a players growth, because if you're thinking of Walcott... Who says even if he didn't go to the world cup he wouldn't be like this, you can't possibly know that it was bad for him.
It'd be naive to think of it as a rule just because of one incident, if it's happened again & again it'd be a valid point.
Zoffie said:Ronaldo was one of the greatest ever, so not a typical example and not really appliable, especially in this context of club appearances and international football for England.
Because when we look back at Ronaldo's career for instance, when was he at his greatest.. El Fenomeno barely 20 & he tore up the Spanish league with something like 47 goals in 49 games.
Zoffie said:My point was club experience, not age as a basis for international selection. Owen played well over 40 games for Liverpool before the 98 World Cup, Rooney has made 77 club appearances over the 2002/3-2003/4 seasons.
We look back at Owen's career when was he at his best, better as a teenager than when he matured. People debated as to whether Rooney should got to Euro 2004, he went, who was Englands BEST player.. & without any big time International experience.
Zoffie said:No - they had club experience.
How well did Germany do in the World Cup, with Khedira, Ozil, Muller.. Did they have big time International experience.
Ozil had played first team football for four season before the World Cup, Muller played 34 times for Bayern in the 2009/10 season and had made quite a few appearances in a next league, Khedira had made nearly 100 appearances for Stuttgart.
Zoffie said:I assume you mention Ronaldo, 17, World Cup and stunting because you've assumed I was talking about Walcott? That was Eriksson's decision. Ronaldo had played not many games for Cruzeiro, one of the main factors why he didn't play in the 1994 tournament I'd say.
Ronaldo went to the World cup in 1994 at 17.. Didn't stunt him.. You look back at more Brazilian greats, Kaka went to the world Cup in 2002, When was Pele's 1st World Cup..
Here you have a NT team that consistently fast tracks their greatest talents into the squads & so if there was a pattern of failure when being called up early it'd surely show up in Brazillian players & surely there wouldn't be so many success stories.
In addition, Kaka had 40-odd games for Sao Paolo before a cameo against Bolivia for his Brazil debut.
Pele is one of the greatest - all three you mention are great players. Using these as examples, when my original point was only about Capello not immediately picking some promising youngsters - who are not this level and never will be - just all seems a bit ridiculous.
Zoffie said:Again, age is not what I'm disputing.
We look at Brazils current 1st team, Pato 21, Neymar 19, Ganso 21, Ramires 23 Luiz 23...
Zoffie said:Manager A = Capello. He fully knows the player by watching him regularly at club level. Doesn't matter if he's sick for the reserves, doesn't matter if he could be a solution to a long-term problem - in the immediate he needs to play club games.
It's easy to come up with theories about why things are wrong & why things won't work, but, if you fail to find multiple examples to back up what you're saying, it doesn't hold much weight.
What I see as patterns are first...
When "manager A" fully knows a player, even if he is being misused by "manager B", when the player goes under "manager A" (who knows his game & how to use him) he flourishes & so calling up a player out of form, or not being used, it shouldn't be out of the question. If an English player isn't better than foreign strikers at United & so doesn't start...
....but, another English player is better than the foreigners at West Brom & starts, it shouldn't mean the one that starts should play.
Second, some of the best players show their best form when they are younger, it'd be a shame to have the NT miss out on that form.
Thirdly, going to International tournaments at a young age without experience does not stunt your growth.

