Goodfella, hopefully we can keep it music. No road beef. I'll be on later, hopefully discuss the actual football but if its a 3-0 scoreline either way, we're very similar, the knives will be out.
Little read for the Liverpool fans....... Its part of a massive piece I read this morning, well researched and well read. Again, I still think Rafa should get another 18 months. I've bolded the small bits about Arsenal for the lurkers in this thread :)
After a week or more of considering what seemed unthinkable seven months ago as Liverpool ended a season with their best points total in two decades, the answers to both questions remain blindingly obvious to me based on the real evidence to hand: yes and yes. And it isn’t blindingly obvious because I think my opinion is right and everyone else’s is wrong. No, you see I am the exact opposite of the hoards of “experts” who have regularly lined up to take shots at Rafael Benitez over the past five and a half years (and particularly in the last four months). It isn’t so much that our attitudes and opinions diverge (which they most certainly have in the past and continue to do in the present). It’s more to do with the fact that I will never claim to or act like I know everything about the game or some issue within it, nor do I ever twist and bend the truth to prove a point. Sometimes the truth hurts, and I tend to accept it when it does.
The reason why I believe that the answers to both questions are blindingly obvious comes down to experience, reasoning, history and simple common sense. If Rafael Benitez is being adjudged to be a poor manager or simply not good enough for Liverpool, then it’s time for me to take up a new sport, it really is. If that’s the case, then many of the things that I thought I had learned, many of the beliefs that I have held, through over two decades of watching football and supporting Liverpool will have been proved wrong. If a man with far less resources than his major rivals in an era where money means so much can have five years of consistently solid, often brilliant work trumped by four months of poor results and performances (part of which coincided with one of the club’s worst ever injury crises), then nobody who takes the reins after him will be safe. It’s “what have you done for me lately” taken to mind-bogglingly ridiculous lengths.
To me it’s a no-brainer. If Benitez truly deserves the sack, then I know absolutely fuck all about football after twenty-four years. I’ve wasted my time, and I need to take up something else.
This is to say nothing of how badly flawed my concept of who we are (“we” being Liverpool F.C.) would be proven to be if Benitez is fired. I thought we were a club largely trading on a glorious history who hadn’t won a League Title in two decades, who had only come anywhere remotely close to doing so twice in the intervening years (1996/97 and 2008/09, the latter under Benitez), whose greatest triumph is those years was a Champions League victory in 2005 (plotted against all the odds by Montse’s husband) after only winning a major trophy in four out of fourteen seasons prior to that pesky Spaniard’s arrival, a club that has finished in the top two only four times in nineteen seasons, which is far behind its rivals in terms of finances and is crippled with debt, which has a stadium that is vastly smaller than most of its major rivals and smaller even than some of its lesser ones (Sunderland, Newcastle, for example), a club where a manager these days will always have his hands tied by unreal expectations set against a lack of resources.
Of course Rafael Benitez should be given the opportunity to recover this situation. There should be no argument about it whatsoever because, as I touched upon earlier and being practical about it, if he is sacked the next man will have just the same amount of hurdles placed in front of him with no guarantees that he will be able to overcome them. Even more importantly, and leaving aside the myriad of football matters about which I know little (they would fill a warehouse, believe me, just like every pundit in the business), there are four absolute certainties that I have learned through twenty-four years of observing the game. These I will continue to believe until Rafa is sacked (at which point I‘ll know that the rules have changed):
1. A manager’s true worth is only proven over time (and by time I mean the long haul - seven years is a far more accurate gauge than seven months, for example);
2. Once a manager has proven his worth, he does not become bad overnight (overnight being a relatively short period of time, for example a portion of a season). He can, however, go through a bad patch, and usually will. Even the very best throughout the history of the game have had barren spells;
3. However, if a manager is truly good, he will recover eventually;
4. Finally, and more often than people would have you believe, a bad run at a football club is very rarely down to one person alone, though it is most often the manager who will pay with his job (and occasionally his reputation).
Naturally, if Rafa gets the bullet, I will have to revise these beliefs because each one of them (founded in historical fact) will have been proven wrong in an era when history increasingly means nothing. But for now, it is certainly crucial to bear the points above in mind when considering Liverpool’s current situation.
Some managers get a glowing reputation very early on based on the odd decent achievement or two, then quickly fade into obscurity. Steve McLaren got “the biggest job in English football” after leading Middlesbrough to their first ever trophy and European final, and having brought some good youngsters through at the Riverside (funny how two Champions League finals and an FA Cup makes Rafa a bad manager in some eyes, but the same eyes see a League Cup win and a 0-4 reverse in a UEFA Cup final as making McLaren the best candidate for the England job). Anyway, as we know, McLaren failed miserably with England and is now managing a small Dutch club (i.e. not Ajax, Feyenoord or PSV), though who knows, maybe he’ll do what Van Gaal did with AZ Alkmaar.
There are many others. John Gregory took over Aston Villa in the late nineties and helped them up the table, making fun of Stan Collymore’s depression (Collymore is a c*nt, but depression is a horrendous ailment) and calling David Ginola fat in the process. The tabloid media loved this guy for the same reason they love Sam Allardyce now - English, straight-talking, and takes no guff from no one. But as we know, Gregory achieved fuck all at Villa really (a 2-0 win over us in his first game seemed to get him far more kudos than anything else he did), and he has since faded into obscurity (didn’t QPR sack him a while back?).
Paul Jewell (took Wigan up, kept them up, sacked by Derby County), Mike Walker (some success with Norwich, failed miserably at Everton), David O’Leary (spent quite a bit at Leeds, won nothing, nearly took Villa down), Kevin Keegan (as much as I like the man, he spent quite a bit at Newcastle and won nothing, and has failed to varying degrees in every other job he’s ever had at the top level), Ruud Gullit (an FA Cup at Chelsea, I believe he has since been sacked in every managerial job he’s held, even the LA fucking Galaxy) and Gianluca Vialli (a couple of trophies with Chelsea, then sacked, also sacked at Watford) are other examples of men anointed by the media too early who were never as good as they were said to be. Glenn Hoddle was another one.
Others have been written off too early, but a manager’s true worth, good or bad, is only seen over the long haul. The Manchester United supporters who held up a banner saying “Ta-ra Mr Alex Ferguson” during the 1989/90 season had given their manager three years up to that point to overhaul a monster that had dominated English football for two decades (Liverpool). Such a job was always going to prove difficult, and it seemed as though Ferguson’s failure to pull it off relatively quickly despite spending quite a bit for the time (more than Dalglish) made him a bad manager in the eyes of some. Of course, this was simply not the case. After all, was this not the man who had broken the Old Firm monopoly in Scotland and led Aberdeen to a Cup-Winners Cup final victory over Real Madrid in the early eighties? In actual fact, Ferguson had had a tremendous managerial record going back almost a decade at that point and had proven himself to be very good at his job. That didn’t seem to matter, but it should have. He would go on to underline his credentials in the most spectacular manner possible over the next two decades. These days, most observers of the game will put him in the frame for greatest British manager of all time.
I can tell you for sure that when Ferguson retires, he will not be remembered as the man who was three and a half years in the Manchester United job by the time he won a trophy, and who managed to finish 11th (in the 1988/89 season) and get battered 5-1 in a Manchester derby in the meantime. More recently, I sat around a dinner table in February 2006 with two Manchester United supporters (not by choice, obviously) who will no doubt conveniently forget now that they wanted him out (I’m sure we all wish that they had gotten their way). And it’s not just Ferguson. Bill Shankly is remembered now as the man who built Liverpool F.C. into a giant of world football and not as the man who went on a seven year stretch between 1966 and 1973 without so much as a single trophy. Meanwhile, Arsene Wenger will not be remembered for taking three years to rebuild his aging, mostly inherited double-winning side of 1998, during which time he won nothing, finished eighteen points behind the champions in 1999/00 and got humiliated 6-1 at Old Trafford in 2001.
No, because the three greats mentioned above survived difficult times during which many of their own supporters often felt like they had lost it, that they would never recover it and that it was time to bring someone in who could. God only knows the kind of ignorant, crass comments that would have been made at Shankly’s expense if the 21st century media machine had been around back then. Seven years without a trophy? Are you kidding? What would Stan Collymore say? Yet Shankly was given the opportunity to rebuild, winning a League and UEFA Cup in 1973 and leaving a rich legacy for his successor, Bob Paisley. These days, there’s a statue of him outside Anfield. Ferguson recovered to become the most successful manager in the history of the English game and as scary as it sounds to us, he will no doubt have a statue outside Old Trafford some day. Arsene Wenger won two more League Titles, created the “Invincibles,” and took Arsenal to their first ever European Cup/Champions League final.
What’s more, it is debatable as to whether each of the individuals mentioned above were solely at fault for their barren spells. Shankly may have taken too long to break up his first title-winning side, but with Don Revie’s Leeds, Matt Busby’s Manchester United, Malcolm Allison’s Manchester City, Brian Clough’s Derby County, Arsenal’s double-winning side of 1971 and Bill Nicholson’s Tottenham all on the scene, it was an incredibly competitive era. Ferguson spent a lot of money and took his team to a lowly 11th place finish, but he was trying to overcome not only Dalglish’s Liverpool, but also George Graham’s Arsenal, the great Everton team of the mid-eighties, and a heavily-invested Tottenham side which included Gascoigne, Waddle and Lineker. What’s more, it was in the last era of true equality in English football, before Sky and the big money arrived, where Luton Town, Coventry City and Wimbledon all won trophies. In many ways, it was equally as competitive a situation as Shankly had experienced back in the late sixties and early seventies.
Meanwhile, Wenger was trying to overcome arguably Manchester United’s greatest ever side, winners of a trio of League Titles between 1999 and 2001, and Treble-victors in 1999. This while attempting to rebuild a back four and goalkeeper nearing retirement (Seaman, Dixon, Winterburn, Bould, Adams). Like Rafa’s Champions League victory in 2005 (which many suggested would take the pressure off, but instead increased it), Wenger’s double in his first full season only raised expectations at a time when major surgery needed to be carried out on his team. Again, the manager was not without fault (the likes of Richard Wright and Francis Jeffers were expensive flops), but given time and a bit of money, he was able to rebuild amidst what were, perhaps, unrealistic demands of both him and his team.Full post (if you have a spare half hour)
http://www.redandwhitekop.com/forum/index.php?topic=251654.0