📖 Grimepedia
An archive of grimeforum.com, 2007–2022. Read-only.
Archive › Sports

The Defenders Debate

23rd October '10, 02:22 PM#1
ArmaniArmyGod Forgive Me If I Press EnterJoined: March 2010Posts: 1,633▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
I was thinking before watching Spurs everton about how little spurrs have in the back and what makes a good defender.

is it the partnership is defenders that forges a world class repuatation which we see all the time e.g. vidic ferdinand or is a world class defender born on individual merits?

i cant think of one defender (central defender in particular) that has a world class reputation based on individual performance that doesnt need the partnership to warrant his status

what do you all think? i'm quite bafled by this tbh

discuss.
23rd October '10, 05:48 PM#2
JoshGrime Forum DonJoined: March 2009Posts: 8,782▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Nesta
Puyol
FREE SHANGER!
23rd October '10, 06:12 PM#3
I LOVE GRIMEGrime Forum OGJoined: February 2009Reppin: SKENGVILLEPosts: 17,576▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Josh said:
Nesta
Puyol
both have always had amazing players around them tbf
1st Stepz Radio Tuesdays 6pm www.Nasty.FM 101.2FM Essex @1stStepz
23rd October '10, 06:17 PM#4
JoshGrime Forum DonJoined: March 2009Posts: 8,782▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
I LOVE GRIME said:
both have always had amazing players around them tbf
The best defenders in the world will always have amazing players around them. What I was going on was that Puyol has had loads of different defensive partners (Abidal, Milito, Oleguer, Marquez, Pique... I could go on) and has always shone. Same with Nesta. It's not like Vidic and Ferdinand or Terry and Carvalho who've been with eachother for a number of years.
FREE SHANGER!
23rd October '10, 10:05 PM#5
AlfieOfficially A Fully Pledged Grime Forum MemberJoined: January 2008Reppin: ♬ ♪Posts: 5,417▮
one to attack the ball... one to clean up

thats why toure and gallas didnt work
Quote: Originally Posted by Quality Control tallorder loves them ordinary, slightly aging peroxide blonde chicks "You know you made it when the police are riding in front of you instead of behind you"

Three Six Mafia
23rd October '10, 11:17 PM#6
The StigPosts: 2,041Since: 2009
Cole is not the best left back in the world

snm
23rd October '10, 11:41 PM#7
`RowNot Just Any GuyJoined: April 2009Posts: 5▮
Who is?
24th October '10, 12:09 AM#8
BIGLEEOfficially A Fully Pledged Grime Forum MemberJoined: March 2010Reppin: LondonPosts: 5,116▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
The Stig said:
Cole is not the best left back in the world

snm
he is
24th October '10, 05:04 AM#9
I LOVE GRIMEGrime Forum OGJoined: February 2009Reppin: SKENGVILLEPosts: 17,576▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
evra
1st Stepz Radio Tuesdays 6pm www.Nasty.FM 101.2FM Essex @1stStepz
24th October '10, 10:25 AM#10
chris89oh hai guise wots goin on itt?iDonateJoined: June 2008Reppin: South West LondonPosts: 19,265▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
The Stig said:
Cole is not the best left back in the world

snm
evra

lol @ you two

I think it's now been pretty much decided that Ashley Cole is better than Evra, considering Cole's consistent world class performances for most of his career and the fact Evra sometimes plays like Stephen Warnock.
chris89 said:
so bitter, you've been in it 14 straight years and never won it, fucking hell we've even been to more finals than you
Hutch said:
Winning it this season was weird tho you're right, I think it means #CrisisAverted
24th October '10, 01:15 PM#11
The DonGrime Forum RegularJoined: July 2008Reppin: Uxbridge roadPosts: 7,369▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
it's difficult to say, a striker is arguably as much at the mercy of those around him but the black and white of impact he has on goals makes it alot easier to argue his case

when you're talking bout reputation of defenders, most people evaluate it similarly to strikers, replacing goals scored for goals conceded and obviously a top tier team will usually concede less because of the overall dominance they have on games anyway but this is sometimes as much to do with shape and midfield as it is defenders qualities

someone like bramble would imo have a much better reputation just for playing at a club like chelsea as he's gonna withstand less pressure, move in a unit much stronger with terry/ivanovic/alex beside him and make less mistakes as a result, overall quality does show in instances but it has alot to do with this i reckon


The Stig said:
Cole is not the best left back in the world

snm
lol fuck off, if i cared more i'd have negged you

there isn't a left back that has the all round qualities and consistently high level like he does

defensively he's sick, attacking wise in terms of finishing/crossing he's not great, but going forward off the ball he's as key to our system as drogba/lampard
24th October '10, 01:41 PM#12
Xtra PSuper ModGrime Forum Duppy MakerJoined: March 2006Reppin: The ban hammerPosts: 26,041▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Lucio >>
Block19 said:
I made gun fingers when they lowered your nans coffin into the ground
Shanger said:
girls r like children except more retarded.
Guerillatoker said:
I've known a few gay people and not one has ever tried to rape me
L.E.V said:
I am living proof that shit evaporates
24th October '10, 03:55 PM#13
EquilibriumGrime Forum OGJoined: January 2008Reppin: Straight & NarrowPosts: 17,226▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
The Don said:
lol fuck off, if i cared more i'd have negged you

there isn't a left back that has the all round qualities and consistently high level like he does

defensively he's sick, attacking wise in terms of finishing/crossing he's not great, but going forward off the ball he's as key to our system as drogba/lampard
trust people are blinded by their opinion of him, agree with all you said and the fact that chelsea can always rely on him to perform in the big games whether he's facing c.ronaldo or messi he will hold his own better than any other left back whilst keeping his cool mostly

24th October '10, 05:14 PM#14
Alter E-ghostGrime Forum OGiDonateJoined: March 2008Reppin: NetherforumPosts: 18,791▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
cole is the best in the world i just dont like him

evra is still sick though
sure.
24th October '10, 05:16 PM#15
EagleTake off my chain, zip up my jacket, Big H's got beef i'm gonna back itiDonateJoined: May 2006Reppin: 2 steps ahead of youPosts: 12,387▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
maicon








w8



wut
used to bounce green by the ounce in a bristol halls
dont try and talk rough bout 8 bars and 9 balls
24th October '10, 05:50 PM#16
ArmaniArmyGod Forgive Me If I Press EnterJoined: March 2010Posts: 1,633▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Eagle said:
maicon








w8



wut
hes a right back sonny
24th October '10, 06:17 PM#17
EagleTake off my chain, zip up my jacket, Big H's got beef i'm gonna back itiDonateJoined: May 2006Reppin: 2 steps ahead of youPosts: 12,387▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
ArmaniArmy said:
hes a right back sonny
well done captain obvious

right back = a defender
used to bounce green by the ounce in a bristol halls
dont try and talk rough bout 8 bars and 9 balls
24th October '10, 06:23 PM#18
GoodFellaYou might also have seen me post as Eater/Lurker/Nine Bar and many others.Joined: December 2009Posts: 2,984▮▮▮▮▮
JT is a world class CB.
24th October '10, 06:44 PM#19
ArmaniArmyGod Forgive Me If I Press EnterJoined: March 2010Posts: 1,633▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Eagle said:
well done captain obvious

right back = a defender
yes, as the OP i did specify central defender and there was a sub convo about left backs so shatap you ill informed twat!
24th October '10, 09:17 PM#20
JoshGrime Forum DonJoined: March 2009Posts: 8,782▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Xtra P said:
Lucio >>
Good shout.
FREE SHANGER!
24th October '10, 10:42 PM#21
The StigPosts: 2,041Since: 2009
The Don said:
lol fuck off, if i cared more i'd have negged you

there isn't a left back that has the all round qualities and consistently high level like he does

defensively he's sick, attacking wise in terms of finishing/crossing he's not great, but going forward off the ball he's as key to our system as drogba/lampard
whattttttttttt

He's fucking shit. All he does when he gets the ball is pass back and Terry is always covering him. Yeh he's good when he goes forward but come on, how you possible think this guy is good at defending...? Smfh

and smfh to all the other people that think he's a good defender

I mean look at this

http://www.soccerclips.net/videos/man-city-1-0-chelsea-tevez3
24th October '10, 11:00 PM#22
PirateGrime Forum EliteJoined: November 2009Posts: 10,834▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Ashley Cole as a forward >>>
As a defender <<<
24th October '10, 11:03 PM#23
The DonGrime Forum RegularJoined: July 2008Reppin: Uxbridge roadPosts: 7,369▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
smh watch 90 minutes of a football match plz both of you

ashley cole the great attacking full back who can't defend is a myth, his strength is summed up in my first post
24th October '10, 11:09 PM#24
Jay05I know man with the whole cookie jar you can roll with your biscuit.iDonateJoined: January 2008Posts: 7,424▮
The Don said:
smh watch 90 minutes of a football match plz both of you

ashley cole the great attacking full back who can't defend is a myth, his strength is summed up in my first post
this

if anything cole is a little lacking going forward and a better defender. His crossing, passing and shooting all could be improved.


In terms of centre backs of it is mental compared to other positions its hard to judge seeing it just on tv and impossible from highlights.

Puyol is very overrated imo, he can put in a crunching challenge but is not a great defender.
http://rapidshare.com/users/RRHRDGfile gone - grime sets i have upped.
24th October '10, 11:13 PM#25
The StigPosts: 2,041Since: 2009
:smh:
24th October '10, 11:16 PM#26
Jay05I know man with the whole cookie jar you can roll with your biscuit.iDonateJoined: January 2008Posts: 7,424▮
If u dont rate Cole, then name 5 better left backs
http://rapidshare.com/users/RRHRDGfile gone - grime sets i have upped.
24th October '10, 11:20 PM#27
Matt91Grime Forum OGiDonateJoined: February 2008Posts: 24,765▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Cole is the best left back

Evra had 1 decent season like his 2nd season for Utd but he's not a serious contender

Lahm>>>>Evra
habits & contradictions
24th October '10, 11:35 PM#28
TriezType To Me Properly Type To Me Like I'm One Of Dem GuysJoined: February 2009Reppin: Ask Your Girl About Me.....Posts: 1,145▮
Nah man Ashley Cole is that guy....
Cant remember the last time ive seen him get hurt
Lets Play Spot The Difference.....
U Gotta Work At 9....But I Gotta Workin 9
25th October '10, 03:48 AM#29
EquilibriumGrime Forum OGJoined: January 2008Reppin: Straight & NarrowPosts: 17,226▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
hang tight the fucking don he knows blue till i fucking die

See the saved original on the Wayback Machine