quality said:
We played 4-4-2 against City and bossed the game. I don't think it's an exaggeration to say we should have won by 3 or 4, massive missed opportunity for the season ahead tbh.
We played with Jovanovic on the left and Kuyt on the right. I have no problem with them playing out there, but we become incredibly static with both of those sort of players both playing out on the wings. There's no over lapping runs, no balls played into space with a chance of them out running or out muscling their respective full backs. N'Gog is a great at holding the ball up but he's quite static going forward. We were crying out for Gerrard in the hole IMO.
All due respect to N'Gog, but for an away game like that I don't know why Poulsen and Lucas weren't paired together, with Gerrard in the hole where he can be more effective, dropping back into midfield when we needed him, but perhaps Hodgson thought it would be too "Rafa" like to play that way, but with N'Gog and Torres further up the pitch who didn't exchange a pass since the first few minutes we were clearly lacking and what worried me was - NOTHING was changed throughout the match.
People gave us the two man team tag, but I always argued against it, but clearly Gerrard was running all over the pitch trying to rescue us at the very least a goal and that was the first time in ages I truly believed we looked like a one man team- Torres bar his flash of brilliance before firing past the far post was obviously not fully fit and wasn't as sharp or as quick. Agger was a problem for nearly all of the goals - why wasn't the established left back played in that position? He was fit!
It is a worry for me that Carragher still makes the team despite turning slower than a guy in a wheelchair, he obviously has a political position in our club because I would like to see a pairing of Agger and Skrtel, and this is an issue I had with Rafa as well, he isn't totally void of criticism from me.
I feel sorry for Hodgson as I quite like him, but I find the lack of criticism and the support given to him by Sky Sports quite nauseating.
He changed 7 players for the Europa league and this was announced as great management for the squad.
Babel scored on the 45th minute just before half time was immediately subbed and then was dropped for the next game.
N'Gog scored against Arsenal and then was dropped for the Europa League game.
We conceded via man marking for the goal.
The total lack of passion against Manchester City.
It becomes clearer on a day to day basis- the media are totally xenophobic and bitter towards Benitez. Everything that he does good is compared to Benitez. Henry Winter has the audacity to talk about "warmth" in the dressing room, that the "passion of the players" will be restored- I saw none of that against Manchester City.
And don't take that the wrong way I'm not judging Hodgson at this early stage I'l give him his whole two year contract to do his job and prove to us his credentials, I'm just pointing out the hypocrisy of the Sky Sports and other media outlets, who were one of the main reasons cited for Benitez being disposed of.
Martin Broughton replying to an email from a fan RE: Benitez sacking "The media don't agree with you"
Rafa's WORST season was 7th. Hodgson has to at least better that- and it looks daunting.
quality said:
I'm coming to the conclusion that formations themselves mean fuck all, but its how the team is set up and how it performs. Hodgson is culpable for the first one, Gerrard etc are at fault for the second, they were woeful against City.
I don't think Gerrard was really at fault at all, if it wasn't for him it would have been a lot worse and I was his biggest critic last season. Lucas for all I defend him, he was anonymous and despite winning a few headers gave away possession a lot.
He's got forward a lot more under Hodgson, which is great, but he needs a lot more confidence. IMO Lucas isn't a bad player at all, he would look immense in a team like Arsenal or Barcelona, as he is made for that sort of football, but with slow players like Kuyt and Jovanovic on the wings, and Carragher hoofing it over his head, it doesn't help him blossom either, despite how poor he performed.
Anyway I've dissected that enough now. Jovanovic isn't as bad as made out despite having an absolute stinker.
quality said:
Also Hij/Kip what are your thoughts on Torres? Is it better to leave him out until he looks a bit sharper? Will he get sharper?
He won't get match fitness without games (I always doubt whether this is true, but all managers/coaches etc say you need games to get fit so I imagine there is some truth in it)
'nuum general said:
Hij, you know like me that the only reason Andy Gray & co don't manage football teams is because it would be unfair for everyone else as they would win every game
:D