📖 Grimepedia
An archive of grimeforum.com, 2007–2022. Read-only.
Archive › Grime Discussion

Producer Competition 2010 discussion thread

2nd July '10, 09:44 PM#41
Oscar_The_GrouchI Type Posts On Spiderman RooftopsJoined: August 2009Reppin: Man like big birdPosts: 470
kyro said:
i would maybe do something like -

1. Recreate/remix a well known grime track
2. Themed - (what mr. Mitch said)
3. The best beat



do it.
2nd July '10, 10:56 PM#42
MoneyManI Type Posts On Spiderman RooftopsJoined: November 2008Reppin: The NorthPosts: 10,002▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Can beats be uploaded on soundcloud/bancamp and them or just divshare etc?
I think no samples or vsts, but a themed round each round is quite a good idea, would maybe make it easier for judges to judge/people to vote as well if they're comparing say 140 Grime with 140 Grime, whereas if its just a freeforall you might have 1 slow hip-hop beat against a fast dubstep ting.
I don't think any remixes should be allowed though, all original beats.
THFC > LFC

I must keep this avatar and sig untill further notice for losing a bet enforced by Hij.
2nd July '10, 11:02 PM#43
DesetAdminhttp://www.soundcloud.com/desetReppin: EdgwarePosts: 6,741▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Nah soundcloud will bait up who produced what, unless you make a fresh new one with no details on it.
2nd July '10, 11:07 PM#44
MoneyManI Type Posts On Spiderman RooftopsJoined: November 2008Reppin: The NorthPosts: 10,002▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
oh yeah :dozey: lol low my dumbness there.
THFC > LFC

I must keep this avatar and sig untill further notice for losing a bet enforced by Hij.
2nd July '10, 11:11 PM#45
mossmade beatzPosts: 1,286Since: 2009
should be just who makes the better beat
2nd July '10, 11:59 PM#46
mistayifType To Me Properly Type To Me Like I'm One Of Dem GuysJoined: April 2010Reppin: West LDNPosts: 1,090▮▮▮▮
i'm up for any comp, sample packs, themes, whatever i'm on it. but i think to give everyone the best chance they have, they should just be able to submit their best tunes. maybe run another comp with stages with different themes to see who's the most versatile producer

http://soundcloud.com/mistayif/mathematics

follow me on twitter @mistayif
like my facebook page mistayif
3rd July '10, 01:26 AM#47
Dust Head1Posts: 410Since: 2010
more than likely the comp will just fall on its arse like last time neway
3rd July '10, 04:29 AM#48
Jack Man Everyday BlatantNever Been TimidJoined: December 2008Posts: 73▮
Deset said:
yeah or even remixing a track
this tbh. Get an acapella of a tune or use lets say the lead melody of an instrumental, but if you want all the entries to be in just one genre make it suited to grime as not everyone can make Funky/House/garage/Hip Hop on this forum as apart from grime we all do various genres so making a theme based on genre would be disadvantageous to people who aren't experienced/dont listen to that genre as its pretty hard to master something in just 2 weeks, otherwise just allow producers to produce in whichever genre they want (this would be best)

Best beat thing seems dead as people will probably just upload tings from ages ago or something pre-made (I know i would) and if you've only been producing for about a year to 2 years you have less tunes to choose from than from someone who's been producing say 4-5 years so imo i would allow that.


Uncle Ruckus said:
Remember no matter how much money you have you will always be a N###a.
3rd July '10, 06:10 AM#49
SantinoIt Don't Make Sense To Me Shit Posters Wanna Send For MeJoined: October 2008Reppin: KentPosts: 2,319▮▮▮▮
Jack Man Everyday Blatant said:
this tbh. Get an acapella of a tune or use lets say the lead melody of an instrumental, but if you want all the entries to be in just one genre make it suited to grime as not everyone can make Funky/House/garage/Hip Hop on this forum as apart from grime we all do various genres so making a theme based on genre would be disadvantageous to people who aren't experienced/dont listen to that genre as its pretty hard to master something in just 2 weeks, otherwise just allow producers to produce in whichever genre they want (this would be best)

Best beat thing seems dead as people will probably just upload tings from ages ago or something pre-made (I know i would) and if you've only been producing for about a year to 2 years you have less tunes to choose from than from someone who's been producing say 4-5 years so imo i would allow that.
.
Forum Gangstas
3rd July '10, 07:42 AM#50
EquilibriumGrime Forum OGJoined: January 2008Reppin: Straight & NarrowPosts: 17,226▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
let me be judge again

3rd July '10, 07:47 AM#51
DesetAdminhttp://www.soundcloud.com/desetReppin: EdgwarePosts: 6,741▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Jack Man Everyday Blatant said:
this tbh. Get an acapella of a tune or use lets say the lead melody of an instrumental, but if you want all the entries to be in just one genre make it suited to grime as not everyone can make Funky/House/garage/Hip Hop on this forum as apart from grime we all do various genres so making a theme based on genre would be disadvantageous to people who aren't experienced/dont listen to that genre as its pretty hard to master something in just 2 weeks, otherwise just allow producers to produce in whichever genre they want (this would be best)
Just grime.
Jack Man Everyday Blatant said:
Best beat thing seems dead as people will probably just upload tings from ages ago or something pre-made (I know i would) and if you've only been producing for about a year to 2 years you have less tunes to choose from than from someone who's been producing say 4-5 years so imo i would allow that.
Well if you have no tunes to choose from, make one. The whole point of the competition is to compete to be the best, and if you cant make a beat better than someone else, well you've lost havent you.
Most of my best beats were made from competitions & deadlines, so the pressure of having to make a beat in 1 - 2 weeks will encourage you to make a banger.
Either way if a theme was involved, someone could simply edit one of their best beats to fit around the theme.
.
3rd July '10, 08:49 AM#52
daspecimenOfficially A Fully Pledged Grime Forum MemberiDonateJoined: October 2008Reppin: Arsenal.... And?!?Posts: 5,189▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
i think there is a get around for everything. as someone else said, if its a theme theres nothing to stop someone from remixing one of their better tunes and entering.

i do like the idea of a remix competition but i think that you will be limiting the number of entrants if you go with anything other than a submit your beat kind of thing

as i said earlier, i don't particularly care.i just wanna enter and if someones shit from 4 years ago is better than my shit today then them >>>> me.
Quote: Originally Posted by Chipmunk Hold tight B-Rabbit
3rd July '10, 10:57 AM#53
mossmade beatzPosts: 1,286Since: 2009
i am up for themes, remixes, original i dont care.
3rd July '10, 11:02 AM#54
DesetAdminhttp://www.soundcloud.com/desetReppin: EdgwarePosts: 6,741▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
ok so we'll go with
1 - Remix
2- Theme
3 - Best beat
Yes?
3rd July '10, 11:08 AM#55
SantinoIt Don't Make Sense To Me Shit Posters Wanna Send For MeJoined: October 2008Reppin: KentPosts: 2,319▮▮▮▮
Deset said:
ok so we'll go with
1 - Remix
2- Theme
3 - Best beat
Yes?
Dont think remix is a good idea people will just put an acapella over one of there beats and call it a remix.
Forum Gangstas
3rd July '10, 11:14 AM#56
DesetAdminhttp://www.soundcloud.com/desetReppin: EdgwarePosts: 6,741▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
lol true true, but actually remixing a beat.
3rd July '10, 11:16 AM#57
SantinoIt Don't Make Sense To Me Shit Posters Wanna Send For MeJoined: October 2008Reppin: KentPosts: 2,319▮▮▮▮
I think it should be.

1. best beat
2. beat beat
3. best beat

safe lol.
Forum Gangstas
3rd July '10, 11:39 AM#58
Lord JusticeYour Posts Sound Out Of Date And Expired I Check My CP, Got Bare AdmiresJoined: January 2009Reppin: Supreme CourtPosts: 4,083▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Deset said:
Nah soundcloud will bait up who produced what, unless you make a fresh new one with no details on it.
Grimeforum needs an account.

Send your tracks in and have them put up in soundcloud for the listeners pleasure, not having to download etc. Just stream the track


Overall, this sounds like a good idea. I'll never win atm having a big block in writing atm. I can't make a melody/bassline to save my life atm lol.

I'll probably enter, but making something completely different to what I'm use to to help me get over this thing.

I think there needs to be some more stricter rules though, you can't just have the best beat wins (I agree for the round 3 yes), but definitely sample pack based and something themed.

Most people moaned about the last sample pack because they were too lazy to shop up the beat loops into 1 shot drum hits for easy programming. Make sure you include: Kick, Snare, 2 Hats, 2 Percs, 1 Shaker, 1 Bass synth, 2 Melodic synths, Random Vox sample, 1 recognisable melodic pattern (must be somewhat recognised in each piece).

Then a theme base, like War scene etc.
"To punish and enslave"
3rd July '10, 11:45 AM#59
DesetAdminhttp://www.soundcloud.com/desetReppin: EdgwarePosts: 6,741▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
I suggested having a gf soundcloud account already, but it would be to long to upload.
Anyway ill sort things out when Ive finished work
3rd July '10, 02:13 PM#60
KaychiGrime Forum EliteJoined: February 2008Reppin: BristolPosts: 10,175▮
im in
3rd July '10, 02:35 PM#61
DesetAdminhttp://www.soundcloud.com/desetReppin: EdgwarePosts: 6,741▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
so whos gonna be part of the judges/panel. I see that equilibrium wants to be one, need another 4 or 5 I guess.
3rd July '10, 02:36 PM#62
KaychiGrime Forum EliteJoined: February 2008Reppin: BristolPosts: 10,175▮
eq
retro
pred
slu wasteguy
hij
3rd July '10, 02:44 PM#63
mossmade beatzPosts: 1,286Since: 2009
i dont see whats wrong with gf soundcloud how long does it take to upload a 4 minute tune like 2 minutes?
3rd July '10, 02:46 PM#64
KaychiGrime Forum EliteJoined: February 2008Reppin: BristolPosts: 10,175▮
mossmade beatz said:
i dont see whats wrong with gf soundcloud how long does it take to upload a 4 minute tune like 2 minutes?
yeah, if people dont have an account, it can still work via drop box.

I dno what it looks like once dropped.
3rd July '10, 02:48 PM#65
mossmade beatzPosts: 1,286Since: 2009
cant they just sent it to one of the judges to upload, and the judges all have access to the account seems fair doesn't it?
3rd July '10, 03:03 PM#66
DesetAdminhttp://www.soundcloud.com/desetReppin: EdgwarePosts: 6,741▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
what I was hoping for, but lemon wasnt up for uploading. fair enough some tunes could be 15mb 320's, that would take a while to up. Maybe somone else not involved in the compo can do the uploading.
3rd July '10, 03:12 PM#67
mossmade beatzPosts: 1,286Since: 2009
Deset said:
what I was hoping for, but lemon wasnt up for uploading. fair enough some tunes could be 15mb 320's, that would take a while to up. Maybe somone else not involved in the compo can do the uploading.
easily solved with a time-limit
3rd July '10, 03:57 PM#68
Jack Man Everyday BlatantNever Been TimidJoined: December 2008Posts: 73▮
Deset said:
Well if you have no tunes to choose from, make one. The whole point of the competition is to compete to be the best, and if you cant make a beat better than someone else, well you've lost havent you.

Most of my best beats were made from competitions & deadlines, so the pressure of having to make a beat in 1 - 2 weeks will encourage you to make a banger.
I see your point here but i think that the beat should be made exclusively for the competition tbh. I agree with the second part totally though.


Uncle Ruckus said:
Remember no matter how much money you have you will always be a N###a.
3rd July '10, 04:11 PM#69
daspecimenOfficially A Fully Pledged Grime Forum MemberiDonateJoined: October 2008Reppin: Arsenal.... And?!?Posts: 5,189▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
still think it should just be a case of submitting a beat and going up againsr the next person and letting the people decide. all beats should be exclusive but if you dont make something new who is ever going to know.

hopefully we can get this sorted and the comp started ASAP
Quote: Originally Posted by Chipmunk Hold tight B-Rabbit
4th July '10, 07:52 PM#70
DesetAdminhttp://www.soundcloud.com/desetReppin: EdgwarePosts: 6,741▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
bump...
Someone needs to organize who the judges are gonna be.
4th July '10, 07:57 PM#71
mossmade beatzPosts: 1,286Since: 2009
bump...
Someone needs to organize how the competition is going to be run.

fixed.
4th July '10, 08:00 PM#72
I LOVE GRIMEGrime Forum OGJoined: February 2009Reppin: SKENGVILLEPosts: 17,576▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
can i enter and be a judge?
1st Stepz Radio Tuesdays 6pm www.Nasty.FM 101.2FM Essex @1stStepz
4th July '10, 08:11 PM#73
kyroGrime Forum RegularJoined: June 2008Reppin: CardiffPosts: 6,230▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Santino said:
Dont think remix is a good idea people will just put an acapella over one of there beats and call it a remix.
How about remixing as in, you use a melody from a well known grime instrumental then put your twist on it. I don't think it would be that hard tbh.


Deset said:
bump...
Someone needs to organize who the judges are gonna be.
You seem to the one taking charge so do what you feel is right. Personally I would use something like -

Remix - Remake and put your twist on a well known Grime instrumental - No acapella's allowed (maybe have it based on a fixed melody, upload a pic if needed to show people how the melody is played IE Dizzee Rascal - Stop Dat

http://img820.imageshack.us/img820/5576/111111e.jpg
(I tried lol)

Theme - Make a beat based upon a sample, sound or area like Jungles, Carnivals, space etc. (Again I think the person who organises this should pick the theme)

The best beat - Upload your biggest beat that you feel could make you win the competition. (Instrumentals only)
PlayStationNetwork: KyRo_08
4th July '10, 08:32 PM#74
DesetAdminhttp://www.soundcloud.com/desetReppin: EdgwarePosts: 6,741▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
No matter what, someone is gonna say that they are going to use a pre-made beat for whatever; remixing another beat, theme etc.
But fuck it, the Remix, Theme, Best beat way is what is gonna be used.

So far we have Eq & ILG for judges. I'll PM a few more so we have at least 5 judges.

If any of you lot have ideas of who will be a good judge then get at them asap.

I'll update original post so that everyone knows whats going on.
4th July '10, 08:38 PM#75
mossmade beatzPosts: 1,286Since: 2009
kyro said:
How about remixing as in, you use a melody from a well known grime instrumental then put your twist on it. I don't think it would be that hard tbh.



You seem to the one taking charge so do what you feel is right. Personally I would use something like -

Remix - Remake and put your twist on a well known Grime instrumental - No acapella's allowed (maybe have it based on a fixed melody, upload a pic if needed to show people how the melody is played IE Dizzee Rascal - Stop Dat

http://img820.imageshack.us/img820/5576/111111e.jpg
(I tried lol)

Theme - Make a beat based upon a sample, sound or area like Jungles, Carnivals, space etc. (Again I think the person who organises this should pick the theme)

The best beat - Upload your biggest beat that you feel could make you win the competition. (Instrumentals only)
.
4th July '10, 08:55 PM#76
The EnigmaGrime Forum OGJoined: August 2006Reppin: iDonate & Im Admin.Posts: 14,009▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
in.

(for judge)
No power of genius has ever yet had the smallest success in explaining existence. The perfect enigma remains...
4th July '10, 09:40 PM#77
DesetAdminhttp://www.soundcloud.com/desetReppin: EdgwarePosts: 6,741▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
updated the original post, any corrections/additions then let me know
4th July '10, 10:03 PM#78
kyroGrime Forum RegularJoined: June 2008Reppin: CardiffPosts: 6,230▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Deset said:
updated the original post, any corrections/additions then let me know
That looks just about all the information one needs. I wish i could enter this but work has me on shit hours all month :sad:. I'll still see if I can do anything with the time I do have though.

I think you should make a new thread when the competition starts though because many people will have checked this thread and probably forgot about it.
PlayStationNetwork: KyRo_08
4th July '10, 10:06 PM#79
mossmade beatzPosts: 1,286Since: 2009
kyro said:
That looks just about all the information one needs. I wish i could enter this but work has me on shit hours all month :sad:. I'll still see if I can do anything with the time I do have though.

I think you should make a new thread when the competition starts though because many people will have checked this thread and probably forgot about it.
.
4th July '10, 10:09 PM#80
DesetAdminhttp://www.soundcloud.com/desetReppin: EdgwarePosts: 6,741▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
The mods are gonna sort that out, front page business and allsorts. A few things might be different from what Ive stated in the original post so we all have to wait until then.

See the saved original on the Wayback Machine