Eagle said:
in 20 years time the trophy cabinet will show that you won the europa league. arsenals will not have a "well done on coming 3rd and having a title challenge until the end of march" trophy
when people produce graphs to show who was the most successful european team in this era, a europa cup will count more than coming 4th and scraping into the champions league.
coming in the top 4 / top 3 is only good if you can make it count and bring in the players needed to go and win competitions whether its the champions league, premiership, fa cup or carling cup. just sitting in the top 3 and sustaining your place whilst never winning anything doesnt count for shit in the grand scheme of things.
to me football is all about winning trophies whilst playing in an attractive and exciting style.
so yeah, winning a cup > not winning a cup
All that said and done are the history books really going to label Tottenham and Portsmouth as stronger teams than Arsenal in the latter half of the decade past simply because of the silverware that they've won? The answer is no.
Silverware is the end game, but I'd rather stay competitive and respected than win a trophy and be less competitive, simply because your chances of winning again are much diminished. It's not just about one trophy.
Basically it's not just about winning a trophy, but being in a position to win them again and again. Any team can have one good cup run. It's much more difficult to do well in a league, so 3rd and 4th place shouldn't be sniffed at especially as any other team would switch for those positions in a heartbeat - including your own.
That's what Liverpool fans have been crying for good league performances for the past 20 years, and now that they finally felt they could push on for a title this has happened to them. They've won plenty of cup competitions in the last 10 years, but ask them if they could trade it all for one league title, most would say yes.
Liverpool are going to have a tough season next year. Once teams in the lower half starting thinking they can nick points of you, they'll put more effort into games. I hope for the good of English football that they build themselves up like Fiorentina did and come back very strong.
Galvatron said:
i think in a whole assessment of the season, an honest assessment arsenal fans will say the team reached or exceed expectations whereas liverpool probably expected to be pushing for the title and still be in the champions league.
.
Back to the OPs point, Liverpool will have had a more successful season, whether that in itself is a 'better' season is down to your opinion of what matters to you more. Personally I'm not sure failure to qualify for the CL is wholly offset by winning the Europa League. I think Arsenal have had a better season than Liverpool, but I accept that I'm pretty biased.