📖 Grimepedia
An archive of grimeforum.com, 2007–2022. Read-only.
Archive › The Studio

Feedback on potential Grime/Dubstep/Rock crossover?

14th February '10, 04:16 PM#1
ajmetzPosts: 22Since: 2009
Hi,

So I heard an orchestral sample I could imagine a grime rapper doing something to, then inspired by dubstep, I chucked on some wobbly bass, then I didn't know what to do, but had this old rock tune idea that was at the same tempo, so stuck it on the end. Everything is pattern/loop based, so the structure and layers can be changed about really easily. The existing structure is just a mishmash of ideas of what combinations might work. Towards the end I start playing about with possible variations of the rock part, introducing new lead.

I have a lot of respect for Grime and Dubstep people, but I can't rap, and the wobbly bass used here is from an old Soundblaster card, and not the synths common to the genre. So, although it's a bit of a low-fi recording and I'll probably produce a higher quality version in a few weeks, I just wanted to get feedback from the grime community, to see if it approaches anything credible, or what you people would do with it / if you see any potential in it.

Thanks for your time,

10473429-90d
14th February '10, 04:26 PM#2
Lyle&PotJoined: February 2010Reppin: Bedknobs and broomsticksPosts: 1,091▮
I like it, except at 50 seconds those weird synths sound too annoying, and the rhodes sound afterwards sounds off beat, I think if you synchronized it a little more it would be better. Also the Rock is nice, but I would prefer it a lot if it just stayed as it was before, it sounds like 2 songs mixed together.

I would just make these two different songs.
14th February '10, 05:03 PM#3
ajmetzPosts: 22Since: 2009
Yeah, it was two songs thrown together really...

Rhodes shouldn't sound off beat, as it's all been snapped to grid, unless you thought the rhythm was out of kilter with the orchestral sample rhythm. But it is arguably at odds to the rest of the tune in terms of audio aesthetic. I had imagined female vocals at that point perhaps. But yeah, I can play about with it, and see if I can get anything more fitting out of the rhodes, unless you think the rhodes needs removing altogether.

The weird synth bit - if it's annoying at 0:50, how's it at 3:12? I used it to add strength to the rhodes in part, but maybe in your view something else should be used to that effect?
14th February '10, 05:25 PM#4
Lyle&PotJoined: February 2010Reppin: Bedknobs and broomsticksPosts: 1,091▮
on 2nd listen it sounds ok, but it sounds too swingy.

And I didn't listen past the first rock bit, I thought it ruined it too much
14th February '10, 05:59 PM#5
ajmetzPosts: 22Since: 2009
Maybe instead of tweaking existing parts, I should come up with a whole new design for the track, in which case I ought to be able to make it more seamless, have a slightly fresh approach and integrate parts better.

Thanks for taking the time to comment.
14th February '10, 06:06 PM#6
Lord JusticeYour Posts Sound Out Of Date And Expired I Check My CP, Got Bare AdmiresJoined: January 2009Reppin: Supreme CourtPosts: 4,083▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
At what point does it sound good?
"To punish and enslave"
14th February '10, 06:30 PM#7
HoutzPosts: 58Since: 2010
this is to random i was like wtf?

See the saved original on the Wayback Machine