📖 Grimepedia
An archive of grimeforum.com, 2007–2022. Read-only.
Archive › The Studio

R&B Jam

3rd February '10, 01:09 AM#1
GrimaceStop Dat Start Dat Rep Dat WhatJoined: October 2008Posts: 227▮
Let me know what you think.

10364285-40b
3rd February '10, 10:25 AM#2
IsaacGrime KidJoined: November 2008Posts: 12▮
Those drums are weak, and your pianos sound far to electronic, play it yourself with feel.

ja
3rd February '10, 11:47 AM#3
GrimaceStop Dat Start Dat Rep Dat WhatJoined: October 2008Posts: 227▮
The drums are supposed to be soft. Its R&B.

Keep doing your DJ Narrows bassline tunes from 2002 and commenting on 10 year old pop stars on youtube.
3rd February '10, 04:40 PM#4
IsaacGrime KidJoined: November 2008Posts: 12▮
Grimace said:
The drums are supposed to be soft. Its R&B.

Keep doing your DJ Narrows bassline tunes from 2002 and commenting on 10 year old pop stars on youtube.
Sorry bro you wanted to know what we thought, and that's my opinion.

If you don't want constructive critisism then don't post, simple as.
3rd February '10, 04:56 PM#5
GrimaceStop Dat Start Dat Rep Dat WhatJoined: October 2008Posts: 227▮
That wasn't constructive. R&B doesn't need hard drums and my piano work is fine.

If I put a beat on youtube I get thousands of views, usually 5 stars and all good comments.

I have only had one comment as bad as that in over 75,000 viewers.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VH7497YF2BQ

So if you know what your talking about talk. If you dont shut up.
3rd February '10, 05:51 PM#6
WizGrime Forum OGJoined: January 2006Posts: 15,902▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
R&B drums are supposed to be soft? go tell that to Polow and Timbaland.

if someone wants to criticize your work don't tell them to "shut up", he was pointing out flaws, if you're not prepared for that then don't post your work here
On a final note: stop calling my music dubstep! It's simply grime without a vocal on top of it wasteguys! You want to hear dubstep listen to DMZ, Youngsta, Loefah, Hatcha - they are the dons and my sound is totally different to that. Next person to write that I am dubstep will get a wonderpalm to the jawside with my Nintendo Powerglove.
- Plastician, 2005
3rd February '10, 06:37 PM#7
GrimaceStop Dat Start Dat Rep Dat WhatJoined: October 2008Posts: 227▮
Its not a Timbaland style track though is it. Tell Pharrel his drums are shit, they were his I used.

I'll tell who I want to shut up thanks. I don't mind your stuff but when shit producers come with shit feedback it comes accross as hate.
3rd February '10, 06:42 PM#8
NSFI'm A King When I Scroll Through GrimeForumJoined: November 2008Reppin: LeedsPosts: 504▮▮▮▮▮
Sounds good, the melodies are nice. I dunno if its these speakers or what but it sounds like the kick needs turning up a little bit, sounds a bit too distant to the rest of the kit but like i said it might be just these speakers. Maybe try adding shakers during certain sections instead of hi-hats to give it a more chilled out/softer vibe?
3rd February '10, 06:52 PM#9
GrimaceStop Dat Start Dat Rep Dat WhatJoined: October 2008Posts: 227▮
NSF said:
Sounds good, the melodies are nice. I dunno if its these speakers or what but it sounds like the kick needs turning up a little bit, sounds a bit too distant to the rest of the kit but like i said it might be just these speakers. Maybe try adding shakers during certain sections instead of hi-hats to give it a more chilled out/softer vibe?
Safe. Made the snare louder so yeah, kick could match it. Went simple on the hats, but could vary them a bit.
3rd February '10, 08:27 PM#10
WizGrime Forum OGJoined: January 2006Posts: 15,902▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
it doesn't matter if you're using someone's drums, if you're not mixing them properly they'll sound shit regardless
On a final note: stop calling my music dubstep! It's simply grime without a vocal on top of it wasteguys! You want to hear dubstep listen to DMZ, Youngsta, Loefah, Hatcha - they are the dons and my sound is totally different to that. Next person to write that I am dubstep will get a wonderpalm to the jawside with my Nintendo Powerglove.
- Plastician, 2005
3rd February '10, 09:29 PM#11
GrimaceStop Dat Start Dat Rep Dat WhatJoined: October 2008Posts: 227▮
My mixings fine. If your giving comments on the mix whist streaming from divshare instead of downloading then they are worthless.
4th February '10, 08:37 AM#12
IsaacGrime KidJoined: November 2008Posts: 12▮
Grimace said:
Its not a Timbaland style track though is it. Tell Pharrel his drums are shit, they were his I used.

I'll tell who I want to shut up thanks. I don't mind your stuff but when shit producers come with shit feedback it comes accross as hate.
You really are ignorant; regardless of what feedback might be and who from, don't take it to heart, but use it - my feedback was constructive because I told you what I thought , and if your not ready for that, then maybe you shouldn't be using the internet?

- and I hope that "s**t producer" was not serious, becuase it sounds like you got some maturing up to do.

Regards
4th February '10, 10:26 AM#13
daspecimenOfficially A Fully Pledged Grime Forum MemberiDonateJoined: October 2008Reppin: Arsenal.... And?!?Posts: 5,189▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Grimace said:
I don't mind your stuff but when shit producers come with shit feedback it comes accross as hate.
I didn't see it as hate at all. The guy had an opinion, a valid and constructive one at that, and you retaliate with childish insults.

I listened to that beat, another r&b one and your a major improv and i really like your work but your attitude stinks.

if you aim to progress as a producer and musician, surely you'd take more from one person saying "vary your drums", "make them harder", "mix them better" than 20 people saying "yo, that's tight bro... send me a link". that might boost your ego but even positive comments can be constructive.... "i like the way you went into the bridge", "really nice chord progressions" etc and again, its far more helpful in the long run than someone just saying hope dope they think it is.

i think if you aim to post more on here, then i hope you'll rectify that because there are a lot of good producers on here with constructive things to say and if you shoot everyone down who doesn't sing from the hills about how fucked you are you'll be posting and getting no replies.

i've posted on here and had negative feedback but i took it away and looked at what was being said and how those areas could be improved and im putting that into the newer stuff i'm working on at the moment and hope to get more constructive feedback when i get round to posting them.

i'm by no means an authoritative figure, but just my 2 pennies worth.
Quote: Originally Posted by Chipmunk Hold tight B-Rabbit
4th February '10, 08:08 PM#14
mossmade beatzPosts: 1,257Since: 2009
Its an okay beat, but tbf you didn't need to tell him to shut up. He didn't do anything. You asked for us to let you know what we think, and he said his opinion he didn't like it and thought the drums we're too weak. If you don't like what people say, don't post, as other people have told.


I liked the piano, I personally thought the drums we're fine, however imo the piano was a bit too loud. But thats just my opinon. No need to kick off and start claiming your g
4th February '10, 11:42 PM#15
GrimaceStop Dat Start Dat Rep Dat WhatJoined: October 2008Posts: 227▮
daspecimen said:
I didn't see it as hate at all. The guy had an opinion, a valid and constructive one at that, and you retaliate with childish insults.

I listened to that beat, another r&b one and your a major improv and i really like your work but your attitude stinks.

if you aim to progress as a producer and musician, surely you'd take more from one person saying "vary your drums", "make them harder", "mix them better" than 20 people saying "yo, that's tight bro... send me a link". that might boost your ego but even positive comments can be constructive.... "i like the way you went into the bridge", "really nice chord progressions" etc and again, its far more helpful in the long run than someone just saying hope dope they think it is.

i think if you aim to post more on here, then i hope you'll rectify that because there are a lot of good producers on here with constructive things to say and if you shoot everyone down who doesn't sing from the hills about how fucked you are you'll be posting and getting no replies.

i've posted on here and had negative feedback but i took it away and looked at what was being said and how those areas could be improved and im putting that into the newer stuff i'm working on at the moment and hope to get more constructive feedback when i get round to posting them.

i'm by no means an authoritative figure, but just my 2 pennies worth.
That other guy commented on the beat too and mentioned the drums. But did it in the right way. Commenting on good and bad not just saying thats shit and thats shit.

The first and strongest thing is the melodies and harmonics in that beat and the first guy didnt mention it at all. Whether the drums are weak all not its still a strong tune, ive got worse beats than that one of my youtube which has had 50,000 views. The guy didnt need to be that blunt, unless he could do better. Which by the sound of his stuff he cant.
4th February '10, 11:58 PM#16
WizGrime Forum OGJoined: January 2006Posts: 15,902▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
You're still being immature about it. People don't have to give positive with a negative, you need to take from the fact that if people find something negative then there's a variable that could need changing in your formula.

Being blunt helps improve, being vague brings pretty much no work at all. You should be happy that he pointed out exactly what was wrong. It's not like he's saying "your beats are shit, why are you making music? give up", he was showing you what could be improved.
On a final note: stop calling my music dubstep! It's simply grime without a vocal on top of it wasteguys! You want to hear dubstep listen to DMZ, Youngsta, Loefah, Hatcha - they are the dons and my sound is totally different to that. Next person to write that I am dubstep will get a wonderpalm to the jawside with my Nintendo Powerglove.
- Plastician, 2005
6th February '10, 12:36 AM#17
Lyle&PotJoined: February 2010Reppin: Bedknobs and broomsticksPosts: 1,091▮
The piano melody is nice, but the synthesis is below par, and the drums sounds are way below par.. So is the mixing. Take it as constructive.

Also needs a bassline, its just strings, piano and drums... The strings are weak btw. Its missing a lot of low end. And the drum pattern is pretty unspectacular. I'd like to work on this though, mind sharing or collabing?

See the saved original on the Wayback Machine