An archive of grimeforum.com, 2007–2022. Read-only.
Archive › Grime Discussion

Official Grimeforum Rating Threads??

9th October '09, 08:01 PM#1
Tony Starks"Check my attitude...give cats the food!"iDonateJoined: January 2008Posts: 25,562▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
To try and get a general consensus on what the forum (and essentially the fans) are rating I was thinking we could introduce rating threads.

Maybe a week after a CD has dropped and the fanboy-excitement has gone we could have threads were each member rates the cd out of 10 or 5. And the average is the rating the cd gets and is a very good indication of what cds the fans rate and recommend. The ratings could be added to grimepedia and let's face it artists all read the forums. If scorcher got 4/10 for STB2 I doubt he woulda even got into the studio and made Lipsin Ting ffs. If H sees SCUK get 9/10 then him and perhaps the rest of Bloodline would line up more of the same.
Was also thinking of adding a post-count restriction on those allowed to vote if its possible to avoid the gross innacuracies of recent vote threads, which I won't get into.

Thoughts?
Nokia said:
Thats because I assume every poster on here IS white, unless I see ID

Too many Dave's trying to be Jermaine.....
9th October '09, 08:03 PM#2
CinematikSoundbwoy MurdererJoined: February 2009Reppin: West MidlandsPosts: 2,632▮
Gd Idea Still
Mazer Rackham said:
3 easton
9th October '09, 08:05 PM#3
On AirJoined: October 2009Posts: 146▮
so a general what u think of this cd? thread

for every cd?
9th October '09, 08:10 PM#4
Matt91Grime Forum OGiDonateJoined: February 2008Posts: 24,765▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Good idea, just to see the general conseus of what others think etc.
habits & contradictions
9th October '09, 08:13 PM#5
SimonCowellOfGrimeCame From The Bottom To The TopJoined: July 2008Reppin: The Seaside.Posts: 2,125▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Yeah, should be done.
9th October '09, 08:14 PM#6
Tony Starks"Check my attitude...give cats the food!"iDonateJoined: January 2008Posts: 25,562▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
On Air said:
so a general what u think of this cd? thread

for every cd?
No that's just discussion

I mean a rating thread. Every member votes out of 10 so statistically you can confidently say this cd>>>>>>>this cd
Nokia said:
Thats because I assume every poster on here IS white, unless I see ID

Too many Dave's trying to be Jermaine.....
9th October '09, 08:18 PM#7
SevenGrime Forum YardieJoined: January 2008Reppin: MobayPosts: 11,699▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
yea
and attach a poll, so you can have proper statistics

عرض والاسترخاء
9th October '09, 08:35 PM#8
LayardBearI'm Levels Above It's Blatant Now Check My PunctuationJoined: June 2009Reppin: S LondonPosts: 910▮
no fuck conformity. For example I didn't like Street Crime UK, but I don't want to see Big H get castrated due to a few peoples who give it 1/10 ect. It will make fans look stupid due to some statistical number. For example I always thought BIDC wasn't "classic!!!!!" until a month ago...

if eeeeeeeveryone wants this shit then at least make a ban for kids below 200 posts or whatsnot.
Quote: Originally Posted by Wiley never be your woman climbed up yesterday thats nice twitter is working
9th October '09, 08:39 PM#9
Nokia\r\n Grime Forum Elite\r\nJoined: July 2008Reppin: 140 Grime StreetPosts: 10,028▮
Good idea, it should be implemented asap.

What is the next big CD that is being released? (should have a trial run). Or do it with a relatively new-ish released album.

Only 1 rule though - should be a requirement of 200 posts to vote.

You might get faggots/fanboys/haters/idiots signing up on 50 alias accounts to try and change the general consensus
[Only registered and activated users can see links. ]
9th October '09, 08:40 PM#10
TrapstarGrime Forum RegulatorJoined: August 2008Reppin: WestPosts: 8,663▮▮▮▮▮
its not a good idea
Trapstar
9th October '09, 08:44 PM#11
Nokia\r\n Grime Forum Elite\r\nJoined: July 2008Reppin: 140 Grime StreetPosts: 10,028▮
Trapstar said:
its not a good idea
It's alot better than what currently happens.

A.) Multiple Threads

B.) One 68 page thread that is too long to read through to try and get a general idea/reaction as to how the forum is feeling it
[Only registered and activated users can see links. ]
9th October '09, 08:50 PM#12
Tony Starks"Check my attitude...give cats the food!"iDonateJoined: January 2008Posts: 25,562▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
What you lot reckon the post-count restriction should be.
50, 100, 200, 500

The higher the restriction the more the votes impact on the overall average though.
Nokia said:
Thats because I assume every poster on here IS white, unless I see ID

Too many Dave's trying to be Jermaine.....
9th October '09, 08:56 PM#13
Matt91Grime Forum OGiDonateJoined: February 2008Posts: 24,765▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
When Dot's CD gets released raise the post count if it's implemented, too many fanboys.
habits & contradictions
9th October '09, 08:58 PM#14
Nokia\r\n Grime Forum Elite\r\nJoined: July 2008Reppin: 140 Grime StreetPosts: 10,028▮
Tony Starks said:
What you lot reckon the post-count restriction should be.
50, 100, 200, 500

The higher the restriction the more the votes impact on the overall average though.
50 or 100 I think thats fair
[Only registered and activated users can see links. ]
9th October '09, 09:33 PM#15
JACK\r\n Officially A Fully Pledged Grime Forum Member\r\nJoined: January 2008Posts: 5,325▮
there's a whole heap of people above 1000 or so that posts for their good, sometimes i try not to acknowledge

if it comes through, fuck the post limit, final result will anyway be crippled
9th October '09, 09:35 PM#16
6Grime Forum EliteiDonateJoined: April 2008Posts: 11,231▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Tony Starks said:
What you lot reckon the post-count restriction should be.
50, 100, 200, 500

The higher the restriction the more the votes impact on the overall average though.
Rep power would be better
9th October '09, 09:44 PM#17
TrapstarGrime Forum RegulatorJoined: August 2008Reppin: WestPosts: 8,663▮▮▮▮▮
Nokia said:
It's alot better than what currently happens.

A.) Multiple Threads

B.) One 68 page thread that is too long to read through to try and get a general idea/reaction as to how the forum is feeling it
Na man its a shit idea face it this is a forum keep it discussion not

''grimeforum rates street crime uk 8/10'' etc

wtf is this :dead:
Trapstar
9th October '09, 09:45 PM#18
JayStarzGrime Forum EliteJoined: January 2009Posts: 11,171▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
should have the 5 mic rating system, in a sub-section on here for releases. All release threads in that sub-section, you can comment and rate accordingly.

but yeh, probs not really worth it.
"In 010 I don't want no friends,
I want business partners,
I see what the dividends did for Carter, Millions...
No I'm thinking Diligent".
9th October '09, 09:51 PM#19
SnareBearStop Dat Start Dat Rep Dat WhatJoined: July 2009Posts: 266▮
people are always gonna have something to say against doing it, who should be able to do it etc.

more hassle than its worth i think.

O shit ive only got 123 posts, that makes my opinion invalid, even though I've listened to grime from day. Sorry i dont write on every fucking thread.
10th October '09, 12:38 AM#20
RIP Jakey\r\n Back in the correct hands.\r\niSupportJoined: January 2006Reppin: Joe\'s mum\'s vagina.Posts: 16,206▮
Could easily be done with a poll if people wanted to do it.
If there wasn't a Wiley, there wouldn't be a Dot Rotten
10th October '09, 01:28 AM#21
PredSuper ModThe nation's favourite modJoined: January 2008Reppin: BasingstokePosts: 12,309▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
SnareBear said:
people are always gonna have something to say against doing it, who should be able to do it etc.

more hassle than its worth i think.

O shit ive only got 123 posts, that makes my opinion invalid, even though I've listened to grime from day. Sorry i dont write on every fucking thread.
Combine those 2 accounts of yours and watch your credibility grow.
http://mypsn.eu.playstation.com/psn/profile/BigPred.png
(Might have to refresh it)
I don't care what she likes, man can't say I'm not top 10 in England, bury anybody disagreeing in an instant, stageshow duppy or sunday Rinse them!
10th October '09, 12:05 PM#22
SnareBearStop Dat Start Dat Rep Dat WhatJoined: July 2009Posts: 266▮
Pred said:
Combine those 2 accounts of yours and watch your credibility grow.
2 accounts?
10th October '09, 12:13 PM#23
GrimesSuper ModI will continue with my wicked waysiDonateJoined: January 2008Reppin: Y'all need mePosts: 39,157▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
allow all this fanboy talk


fanboys are all around
10th October '09, 12:18 PM#24
JWoulfIt Don't Make Sense To Me Shit Posters Wanna Send For MeJoined: September 2008Posts: 2,318▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
you will have to wait more than a week to get a proper result. It took about 6 months for people to admit RIP yd, wasnt that good, 6 months before people gave an honest rating of ultrasound. It will be the same with Big H. It takes time for the smoke to clear
More gunshots

10th October '09, 12:20 PM#25
The Don\r\n Grime Forum Regular\r\nJoined: July 2008Reppin: Uxbridge roadPosts: 7,369▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
200

was thinking 500 but there are guys that are new to the forum/don't post alot that know what they're on about

i like the idea still
10th October '09, 12:23 PM#26
JayHibernatingiSupportJoined: February 2009Posts: 7,717▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Grimes said:
allow all this fanboy talk


fanboys are all around
bandwagoned term now

we can't restrict the voting by post count and if we have enough people voting anyway a few dodgy votes from low post counters etc shouuldn't really effect the overall score
10th October '09, 12:31 PM#27
CurpheyYou'll Never Walk AloneJoined: February 2009Reppin: Durrrrty SouthPosts: 3,302▮
Sounds like a sick idea n/b.

I'd like this.
http://www.rewards1.com/index.php?referrer_id=469805

Sign up, get free stuff. It works. Google it. That's my refferal link, so if you sign up and do some offers I will earn a few points. Safe.
10th October '09, 12:49 PM#28
BoogaGrime Forum RegularJoined: October 2008Reppin: At RandomPosts: 6,325▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
very good idea. Should be 100 post minimum.
And you're right about artists watching the forums, so they would see what people really think and instead of making tunes like Lipsin Ting, they'll make No Base
Quote: Originally Posted by Wiley Apologise If I Say, Suck Your Mum To Haters Who Don't Like Me
10th October '09, 01:00 PM#29
LayardBearI'm Levels Above It's Blatant Now Check My PunctuationJoined: June 2009Reppin: S LondonPosts: 910▮
Pred said:
Combine those 2 accounts of yours and watch your credibility grow.
lol I was JOKING :P

I just was suprised we had the same name. Safe Bear.
Quote: Originally Posted by Wiley never be your woman climbed up yesterday thats nice twitter is working
10th October '09, 01:07 PM#30
RetrofreakSuper ModRadio is dead... Music lives on in the minds of the free!!Posts: 13,831▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
It would need to be score system based, so you can rate various points of the CD/Artist or it will fail, due personal opinion.
The Victorious Warrior First Wins Then Seeks Battle
The Defeated Warrior First Battles Then Seeks Victory
- Sun Tzu
10th October '09, 03:16 PM#31
M.O.G.Grime Forum OGiDonateJoined: January 2009Reppin: HackneyPosts: 14,537▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Trapstar said:
its not a good idea
Didnt even list any reasons as 2 why it would be a bad idea smh.
10th October '09, 03:19 PM#32
Quality ControlGrime Forum OGJoined: January 2008Reppin: Quality & QuantityPosts: 30,950▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Don't think we need to make a big fuss and bother with "officialty"... Just make a thread after a CD has dropped init.
Quote: Tempa T’s take on the aggressive black male terrorising nice white students in Next Hype is only initially rather alarming
10th October '09, 03:21 PM#33
TrapstarGrime Forum RegulatorJoined: August 2008Reppin: WestPosts: 8,663▮▮▮▮▮
Quality Control said:
Don't think we need to make a big fuss and bother with "officialty"... Just make a thread after a CD has dropped init.
get me
Trapstar
10th October '09, 03:25 PM#34
The MessiahSuper ModThe Grime Forum DoctorReppin: The EndsPosts: 19,250▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Retrofreak said:
It would need to be score system based, so you can rate various points of the CD/Artist or it will fail, due personal opinion.
I'm with you on this. There should be headings for areas (broadly speaking) lyrics/flow, instrumental quality, concept etc. and then an overall global score.
SKENGMAN MODE said:
your not real life... just something of the internet

See the saved original on the Wayback Machine