📖 Grimepedia
An archive of grimeforum.com, 2007–2022. Read-only.
Archive › Grime Discussion

Calls grow to scrap 'potentially racist' Form 696 as music industry suffers

31st August '09, 01:42 PM#1
spliffyGod Forgive Me If I Press EnterJoined: April 2008Reppin: EndzPosts: 1,527▮
Police say it has curbed gun crime at clubs and played a role in reducing serious violence on the London music scene. But musicians, politicians and figures from the entertainment industry have now called on the government's equalities watchdog to intervene in the controversy over the Metropolitan police's Form 696, which they claim is "potentially racist". Opponents fear that the Met scheme will be adopted by forces nationwide.

Form 696 asks venues to provide the name, address and contact telephone numbers for artists and promoters. When the layer of red tape was introduced, it also asked for details of which ethnic group was likely to attend the proposed event.

That requirement was dropped last year after widespread criticism, but the form still asks promoters to say what style of music is to be played and gives "bashment, R&B, garage" as examples – all of which are styles of music popular with black and Asian fans.

"To me it is quite remarkable that anyone could have thought this level of intrusion was a good idea," said Feargal Sharkey, the former lead singer of the Undertones and now chief executive of UK Music, who is one of the signatories of a letter to the Equalities and Human Rights Commission (EHRC), asking it to intervene.

"The form is clearly targeting styles of music that are popular with people from ethnic minority communities and that seems extraordinary in today's modern, diverse multicultural London."

The organiser of the appeal to the EHRC, journalist Sunny Hundal, said that although the form was "voluntary", many events had applications for licences turned down after refusing to fill it in.

"There is a deep sense of unease among many within the music scene that it is being used to target events by black or Asian organisers," he said. "With live events being an integral part of the music scene, this only makes life harder for everyone and denies the people of London a diverse range of entertainment."

The letter, which has more than 50 signatories, states: "We are deeply concerned that Form 696 has the potential to be misused by the police to discriminate against ethnic minorities … There is now a danger that police across the country will adopt this measure and further entrench this illiberal and potentially racist practice."

Police have defended their use of the form, saying it has helped reduce violence at certain London music events and "played its part" in an 11% drop in serious violence at venues in 2008.

However, a report by the Commons culture media and sport select committee, published in April, said: "Such a form goes well beyond the requirements of the licensing act and has a detrimental effect on the performance of live music. We recommend that Form 696 should be scrapped."

The Met said the form was still being used but was under review, and a decision about its future would be made next month.

A Met police statement said: "Following concerns expressed by various groups about the form, it is right that we consider whether it meets the requirements of all those involved in the risk assessment process."

However, campaigners and music promoters remain unconvinced.

Rahul Verma, a journalist specialising in urban music, said whole genres were under threat: "It is very difficult to find a grime night in London now because of the use of this form. This is because it has been used to stereotype certain urban music events which are being unfairly associated with violence and trouble."

Hundal, who is the editor of the political blog Liberal Conspiracy, said police assurances that the form was being reviewed did not inspire confidence.

"Unless the Met withdraw this needless layer of bureaucracy, we can't simply accept their assurances that it's under review – they've been saying that for ages."

Singling out beats of bashment, R&B and garage

Bashment, R&B and garage – the three styles of music explicitly singled out in the Metropolitan police's Form 696 – are all dance genres associated with a predominantly young, black audience. Bashment, also known as dancehall, updates traditional reggae with digital beats and faster tempos; thanks to the influence of the British Jamaican community, one of the world's largest overseas Jamaican populations, it has historically had a strong cultural presence and core fanbase in the UK.

At its most club-oriented, bashment combines rowdy rhythms with often sexually explicit lyrics. Aimed squarely at getting dancefloors moving, the genre is known for the dance crazes that periodically sweep it, among them the Gully Creeper performed by the sprinter Usain Bolt following his 2008 Olympic victories. Current artists of stature within the genre include Mavado, Busy Signal and Ce'cile.

The constantly evolving UK garage scene has taken many forms over the past decade, ranging across a wide aesthetic spectrum. Two-step, a smooth, melodic R&B-influenced sound, dominated around the turn of this century, with producers such as MJ Cole and The Artful Dodger finding chart success. By contrast, grime boasted harsher beats, metallic textures and a focus on MCs who dealt with the realities of inner-city life in uncompromising, often aggressive terms; recently, artists such as Dizzee Rascal and Tinchy Stryder have found mainstream success with lyrics about partying and relationships. Though grime's relationship with the law has always been somewhat uneasy, with the scene growing through illegal raves and pirate radio stations, its reputation for violence was overstated.

A northern iteration of garage, bassline house, is – as its name suggests – marked out by heavy basslines as well as high-pitched vocals and relentless, four-to-the-floor beats. Currently, the dominance of UK funky house is indicative of a shift among garage clubbers back towards the smoother, female-friendly days of two-step. UK funky DJs and producers often cite "good vibes" in clubs as key, and UK funky club nights are overwhelmingly friendly, glamorous affairs.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2009/aug/30/form-696-ehrc-discrimination-music
Anytime you see me wearing a glove boy better know it's winter.
31st August '09, 02:04 PM#2
skywalkerJoined: January 2008Reppin: E10Posts: 1,371▮▮▮
old news
....


Dont Fuck Around Dans Half Paddy,
The Other Day Your Son Called Me Daddy...
31st August '09, 02:10 PM#3
tdoubleuPosts: 8Since: 2009
skywalker said:
old news
....
.

but good read
31st August '09, 02:10 PM#4
The ElijahiSupportReppin: Rinse FMPosts: 9,554▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
theres basically been no development in this
31st August '09, 02:22 PM#5
spliffyGod Forgive Me If I Press EnterJoined: April 2008Reppin: EndzPosts: 1,527▮
It's a new article so I thought I'd post it.

Take it as you wish.
Anytime you see me wearing a glove boy better know it's winter.
31st August '09, 03:53 PM#6
lozza bI Type Posts On Spiderman RooftopsJoined: January 2009Reppin: BushPosts: 430▮
its a tough one, cause while it is potentially racist and we know the MET have been abusing it, how can we disagree with the fact that there is going to be more hype and stabbings/bottlings as a result at a grime rave than at a DnB/dubstep night, for example? hard to find the balance between prevention and discrimination here but blindly waving the race card without acknowledging that it's a violent scene with violent members is not the look.
im a gooner so u dont wanna test this arsenal
31st August '09, 03:59 PM#7
Mazer RackhamSuper ModGrime Forum OGJoined: January 2009Reppin: the sticksPosts: 26,778▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
i think the key here is to go to house raves and stab guys
sleeveOFheartz said:
@L.E.V swims around in sewage before church to evaporate his demons
Virus98 said:
Another thread about Papa pt2345545642
31st August '09, 04:07 PM#8
SPOOKY DJJoined: February 2008Reppin: 140 Grime StreetPosts: 4,930▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
we all know feds are racist. no doubt the shooting at The Hill on friday and the shooting close to Ministry yesterday which resulted in someone losing their life (this was the Back To 95 event) is gonna add more fuel to the fire.
31st August '09, 04:24 PM#9
AndreGrime Forum OGJoined: December 2008Reppin: Fire and SmokePosts: 44,603▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
if the music isn't the cause...why is there rarely serious violence at punk shows?
I ain't really care, see my mind's elsewhere like, I ain't really here
31st August '09, 04:43 PM#10
lozza bI Type Posts On Spiderman RooftopsJoined: January 2009Reppin: BushPosts: 430▮
Andre said:
why is there rarely serious violence at punk shows?
i wont pretend to know the answer to that question for fact but from what ive managed to pick up from the few punks i know, there's more comradery / sense of belonging in the punk scene, as its more of a movement/ethos/way of life as well as just a genre of music (anarchy etc etc). you couldnt say grime is any of those because of all the warring and beef. could be COMPLETELY wrong though.
im a gooner so u dont wanna test this arsenal
31st August '09, 04:46 PM#11
AndreGrime Forum OGJoined: December 2008Reppin: Fire and SmokePosts: 44,603▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
so are you suggesting there is a problem with the fans rather than the music?
I ain't really care, see my mind's elsewhere like, I ain't really here
31st August '09, 04:53 PM#12
lozza bI Type Posts On Spiderman RooftopsJoined: January 2009Reppin: BushPosts: 430▮
nah not a problem with the fans, just a problem with how we grow up in london these days. thats probably the largest influence overall, and thats for sociologists to argue over.

i dont have a solution, i only know this law/form 696 is bad news.
im a gooner so u dont wanna test this arsenal
31st August '09, 05:01 PM#13
AndreGrime Forum OGJoined: December 2008Reppin: Fire and SmokePosts: 44,603▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
so why dont punk shows in london have problems with violence
I ain't really care, see my mind's elsewhere like, I ain't really here
31st August '09, 05:04 PM#14
'nuum generalGrime Forum OGJoined: January 2006Reppin: HullPosts: 17,188▮
Andre said:
so why dont punk shows in london have problems with violence
its a different demographic that generally attends them
The Myth
31st August '09, 05:08 PM#15
AndreGrime Forum OGJoined: December 2008Reppin: Fire and SmokePosts: 44,603▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
so you're suggesting that the demographic that attend grime raves are instinctively violent

which demographic would you say this is?
I ain't really care, see my mind's elsewhere like, I ain't really here
31st August '09, 05:14 PM#16
Mazer RackhamSuper ModGrime Forum OGJoined: January 2009Reppin: the sticksPosts: 26,778▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
what event was on at the ministry when the shooting happened. was there even an event on?
sleeveOFheartz said:
@L.E.V swims around in sewage before church to evaporate his demons
Virus98 said:
Another thread about Papa pt2345545642
31st August '09, 05:30 PM#17
'nuum generalGrime Forum OGJoined: January 2006Reppin: HullPosts: 17,188▮
Andre said:
so you're suggesting that the demographic that attend grime raves are instinctively violent

which demographic would you say this is?
instinctively, no. I think it would be fair to say that your average grime artist comes from somewhere which is more violent than your average punk artist though


Mazer Rackham said:
what event was on at the ministry when the shooting happened. was there even an event on?
It was back to 95 I think
The Myth
31st August '09, 05:33 PM#18
AndreGrime Forum OGJoined: December 2008Reppin: Fire and SmokePosts: 44,603▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
'nuum general said:
instinctively, no. I think it would be fair to say that your average grime artist comes from somewhere which is more violent than your average punk artist though



It was back to 95 I think
so the artists are violent people because of their environment?

seems to justify the form really
I ain't really care, see my mind's elsewhere like, I ain't really here
31st August '09, 05:34 PM#19
adidasgrandadGrime Forum OGiDonateJoined: January 2008Posts: 18,968▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
whatever happens....people still have to learn to behave.
smokey joe - "Mik looks likes a turtle"
31st August '09, 11:48 PM#20
casualJoined: January 2008Reppin: Forest Gate, East London.Posts: 2,204▮▮▮▮▮
Mazer Rackham said:
i think the key here is to go to house raves and stab guys
I lol'd
'' Only when you realize how much you don't know, that is when you really know. ''
31st August '09, 11:49 PM#21
GrimesSuper ModI will continue with my wicked waysiDonateJoined: January 2008Reppin: Y'all need mePosts: 39,157▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
truth and racism
1st September '09, 12:16 AM#22
4737Your Posts Sound Out Of Date And Expired I Check My CP, Got Bare AdmiresReppin: GlasgowPosts: 4,404▮
Andre, the reason there isn't violence at Punk shows (most of the time, unless you're talking about hardcore punk, which is another matter) is because they're generally populated by middle class kids who listen to happy clappy tunes and don't want beef.

RAMP014 (Murda Skank/Quack) available on 12", MP3 and FLAC at Boomkat.
Forthcoming 2009 releases on Ramp (UK), Wireblock (UK), Rwina (NL) & more (tbc).
1st September '09, 12:20 AM#23
AndreGrime Forum OGJoined: December 2008Reppin: Fire and SmokePosts: 44,603▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
4737 said:
Andre, the reason there isn't violence at Punk shows (most of the time, unless you're talking about hardcore punk, which is another matter) is because they're generally populated by middle class kids who listen to happy clappy tunes and don't want beef.
yeah i was talking about hardcore punk but most people on here would not know what that is

i used to go to roughly 3 hardcore punk shows a month from camden to brixton and never encountered any serious violence.
I ain't really care, see my mind's elsewhere like, I ain't really here
1st September '09, 12:37 AM#24
4737Your Posts Sound Out Of Date And Expired I Check My CP, Got Bare AdmiresReppin: GlasgowPosts: 4,404▮
Andre said:
yeah i was talking about hardcore punk but most people on here would not know what that is

i used to go to roughly 3 hardcore punk shows a month from camden to brixton and never encountered any serious violence.
Depends on the bands and their following. For example, I wouldn't suggest going to LBU shows and chatting shit, or you'll end up with your teeth sticking thru your lip. With a lot of the proper underground UKHC stuff, there's a definite gang mentality (although it's pretty much developed from the USHC scene - watch Boston Beatdown for example).

RAMP014 (Murda Skank/Quack) available on 12", MP3 and FLAC at Boomkat.
Forthcoming 2009 releases on Ramp (UK), Wireblock (UK), Rwina (NL) & more (tbc).
1st September '09, 12:51 AM#25
AndreGrime Forum OGJoined: December 2008Reppin: Fire and SmokePosts: 44,603▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
4737 said:
Depends on the bands and their following. For example, I wouldn't suggest going to LBU shows and chatting shit, or you'll end up with your teeth sticking thru your lip. With a lot of the proper underground UKHC stuff, there's a definite gang mentality (although it's pretty much developed from the USHC scene - watch Boston Beatdown for example).
take converge for example.

their shows are essentially fights but its not really violent. few broken noses but no stabbings or anything.

even skinhead shows ive been to there hasnt been serious violence
I ain't really care, see my mind's elsewhere like, I ain't really here
1st September '09, 01:39 AM#26
4737Your Posts Sound Out Of Date And Expired I Check My CP, Got Bare AdmiresReppin: GlasgowPosts: 4,404▮
Andre said:
take converge for example.

their shows are essentially fights but its not really violent. few broken noses but no stabbings or anything.

even skinhead shows ive been to there hasnt been serious violence
I'm not really talking the faggy scene kid karate nonsense, I'm more talking about people who will fuck others up at a show if they get out of line.

Mainly, though, people go to shows to have a good time and most people get along because they feel like part of a scene. If people come and disrespect, that's when things kick off.

RAMP014 (Murda Skank/Quack) available on 12", MP3 and FLAC at Boomkat.
Forthcoming 2009 releases on Ramp (UK), Wireblock (UK), Rwina (NL) & more (tbc).
1st September '09, 01:41 AM#27
AndreGrime Forum OGJoined: December 2008Reppin: Fire and SmokePosts: 44,603▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
4737 said:
I'm not really talking the faggy scene kid karate nonsense, I'm more talking about people who will fuck others up at a show if they get out of line.

Mainly, though, people go to shows to have a good time and most people get along because they feel like part of a scene. If people come and disrespect, that's when things kick off.
which is why i said converge
I ain't really care, see my mind's elsewhere like, I ain't really here
1st September '09, 12:03 PM#28
usgrimekingPost Ina Thread, Post Ina Thread Nobody Wants Your Post Ina ThreadJoined: August 2008Reppin: USAPosts: 731▮▮▮
Too many racial undertones these days. Out here, we finally get a black president and conservative groups are hopping mad @ everything he does.
"jj no excuses i put it clear 2 u init u called out urban dva only done his job u sent so your goin to get a reply dnt crry wolf u tryed slew urban so your reply is tommorow an ps im not sayin this light handeadly if your a bad boi clash any dj on urban if urbans shit bak your tlk no more chattin g"
-UrbanFMTV (real internet radio beef!!)
1st September '09, 12:20 PM#29
Tony Starks"Check my attitude...give cats the food!"iDonateJoined: January 2008Posts: 25,562▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Mazer Rackham said:
i think the key here is to go to house raves and stab guys
:laugh: is it wrong that I really can't see any other alternative
Nokia said:
Thats because I assume every poster on here IS white, unless I see ID

Too many Dave's trying to be Jermaine.....
1st September '09, 12:37 PM#30
AndreGrime Forum OGJoined: December 2008Reppin: Fire and SmokePosts: 44,603▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
yeah getting funky raves locked off would definitely lead to more grime raves
I ain't really care, see my mind's elsewhere like, I ain't really here

See the saved original on the Wayback Machine