📖 Grimepedia
An archive of grimeforum.com, 2007–2022. Read-only.
Archive › Grime Discussion

american hip-hop has commercial success, but grime doesn't

28th July '09, 11:59 PM#1
lunoType To Me Properly Type To Me Like I'm One Of Dem GuysJoined: May 2009Posts: 1,192▮
(continued from the shitstorm thread about indie kids)

why is this. i grew up in east london and had to move to america right around the golden age of grime. (2004).

here in america you can make a song detailing how to cook up crack or a graphic song about shooting people with sawed-off shotguns and you will sell and sell and sell some more.

in london for some reason you man think that you need to water down your sound to reach commercial success. maybe you do. mainly tho i'm amazed at how ultra-violent and realistic hip-hop made by project kids can easily reach commercial success here.. and then london's grime never properly gets its dues.


in my opinion grime isn't dead, it's just getting started, we just need to bring griminess back into grime. we need more slew dems, more roll deeps, more nastys. we dont need marvell, "skywalker/wretchroboys" and giggs and them.

i think we can do this if we
1. have faith in our scene
2. contribute to our scene
3. make the scene grow

the scene needs to grow to stay grimy and alive. its up to all the grime artists to steer grime in the direction it needs to go.. that way growth wont lead the scene to shittiness. artists need to make grime, and if they make grime, and the scene grows and most people are making grime, then the market will be forced to recognize the existence of grime.

in hip hops early days them man didnt make much money, just made their little dubplates and sold them around the projects but they kept the scene what it was and helped it grow. now big names in hip-hop are making at least 7 or 8 figures.

you grime people are trying to run before you can walk. your scene has hardly even started yet. dont get discouraged and kill it before you know what it'll become. you need to help grime grow, keep grime grimey, and in time grime artists will be able to reach commercial success without watering down their sound.

shit thats a lot of text
-
29th July '09, 12:01 AM#2
RetrofreakSuper ModRadio is dead... Music lives on in the minds of the free!!Posts: 13,831▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
The Victorious Warrior First Wins Then Seeks Battle
The Defeated Warrior First Battles Then Seeks Victory
- Sun Tzu
29th July '09, 12:02 AM#3
EquilibriumGrime Forum OGJoined: January 2008Reppin: Straight & NarrowPosts: 17,226▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
they sell and sell cos the negative shit they do isnt happening on their consumers doorsteps

29th July '09, 12:03 AM#4
wudI Ain't One Of Those Posters That You Wanna Go AgainstJoined: March 2009Posts: 1,958▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
america isnt the uk

everyone is a wannabe gangster there, no-one in the uk is a wannabe thug
29th July '09, 12:06 AM#5
RetrofreakSuper ModRadio is dead... Music lives on in the minds of the free!!Posts: 13,831▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
London is smaller than New York.

You can go gold selling to your own crowd in one borough alone without leaving the state.

Demographic.
The Victorious Warrior First Wins Then Seeks Battle
The Defeated Warrior First Battles Then Seeks Victory
- Sun Tzu
29th July '09, 12:18 AM#6
BluntwunCame From The Bottom To The TopJoined: January 2008Reppin: BLATANTLY BLUNT, N. LDNPosts: 2,124▮▮
There are a lot more people to buy that in usa dont forget. And grime like hiphop has its hard bodied stuff along side the commerical aimed soft stuff.
29th July '09, 12:19 AM#7
Quality ControlGrime Forum OGJoined: January 2008Reppin: Quality & QuantityPosts: 30,950▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
grime artists are having loads of success at the moment
Quote: Tempa T’s take on the aggressive black male terrorising nice white students in Next Hype is only initially rather alarming
29th July '09, 12:19 AM#8
HighlanderI Type Posts On Spiderman RooftopsJoined: May 2009Posts: 422
america isnt the uk

everyone is a wannabe gangster there, no-one in the uk is a wannabe thug:stunned:
29th July '09, 12:22 AM#9
BluntwunCame From The Bottom To The TopJoined: January 2008Reppin: BLATANTLY BLUNT, N. LDNPosts: 2,124▮▮
I think the 2nd part of that sentence is more shocking than the 1st
29th July '09, 12:25 AM#10
EquilibriumGrime Forum OGJoined: January 2008Reppin: Straight & NarrowPosts: 17,226▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Bluntwun said:
I think the 2nd part of that sentence is more shocking than the 1st
lol

29th July '09, 12:34 AM#11
[D]I Make Posts On A RegularJoined: March 2009Posts: 104▮
No one's "selling" anymore in America anyway.

they days where someone can just put out an album and go platinum are OVER. only a few big stars actually sell well. sort of like here.....



people need to stop watching 10 year old episodes of Cribs.
29th July '09, 12:37 AM#12
The EggheadMy Fingers Type Like They're Powered MechanicallyJoined: April 2008Reppin: Radford,Coventry.Posts: 2,892▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Hiphop has taken 20 years+. Grime aint been around for half that.
If you seen what the skeng done to his head, the judge would have gave me life that day!
29th July '09, 12:38 AM#13
lunoType To Me Properly Type To Me Like I'm One Of Dem GuysJoined: May 2009Posts: 1,192▮
Highlander said:
america isnt the uk

everyone is a wannabe gangster there, no-one in the uk is a wannabe thug
:stunned: people are this dumb?

and also, about "this shit isn't happening on their consumer's doorsteps". it's not happening on yours either. do you really get your windows lenged out every night, and get jacked for your things every time you leave the house? do you see fiends on your corner? of course not. even i don't, really, and i live in a really bad area. :S there are as many sweetboys buying grime as there are sweetboys buying hip-hop. you're not in a position to say that everyone in london who buys grime is a badman in a bad area. i can see why you would want it that way, out of pride, but it's not that trust me.

i suppose it could be because america is just a lot larger than the uk, but.... :sad: it can't be just that. if it is, i'm disappointed.
-
29th July '09, 12:41 AM#14
GrimesSuper ModI will continue with my wicked waysiDonateJoined: January 2008Reppin: Y'all need mePosts: 39,157▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
successful hiphop is watered down.

hiphop isn't restricted in lyrical content or musical sound as is grime.
29th July '09, 12:43 AM#15
RetrofreakSuper ModRadio is dead... Music lives on in the minds of the free!!Posts: 13,831▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Grimes said:
successful hiphop is watered down.

hiphop isn't restricted in lyrical content or musical sound as is grime.
.
The Victorious Warrior First Wins Then Seeks Battle
The Defeated Warrior First Battles Then Seeks Victory
- Sun Tzu
29th July '09, 12:43 AM#16
AndreGrime Forum OGJoined: December 2008Reppin: Fire and SmokePosts: 44,603▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
sound aint as big
I ain't really care, see my mind's elsewhere like, I ain't really here
29th July '09, 12:44 AM#17
GrimesSuper ModI will continue with my wicked waysiDonateJoined: January 2008Reppin: Y'all need mePosts: 39,157▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
when hiphop artists make commercial orientated music it is still packaged as hiphop when grime artists make commercial orientated music it no longer resembles grime in any form.
29th July '09, 12:45 AM#18
RetrofreakSuper ModRadio is dead... Music lives on in the minds of the free!!Posts: 13,831▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Grime is it's own worst enemy.
The Victorious Warrior First Wins Then Seeks Battle
The Defeated Warrior First Battles Then Seeks Victory
- Sun Tzu
29th July '09, 12:46 AM#19
AndreGrime Forum OGJoined: December 2008Reppin: Fire and SmokePosts: 44,603▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
plus hip hop artists make anthems
I ain't really care, see my mind's elsewhere like, I ain't really here
29th July '09, 12:48 AM#20
RetrofreakSuper ModRadio is dead... Music lives on in the minds of the free!!Posts: 13,831▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Hip Hop consist of and fuses with "anything", Grime is stuck in a tempo range with limited emotion.
The Victorious Warrior First Wins Then Seeks Battle
The Defeated Warrior First Battles Then Seeks Victory
- Sun Tzu
29th July '09, 12:50 AM#21
EliteGrimeKidI'm a man with a lot of Pride So it's standard I gotta typeJoined: March 2009Posts: 618▮
how can you say forget marvel, scorcher, etc. they are like our biggest chance.. do u expect people like terminator to hit mainstream and attract listeners worldwide
SOME MAN ARE QUOTING AGAIN, DONT REALISE WHAT THEY'RE POSTING AGAIN.
29th July '09, 12:56 AM#22
AndreGrime Forum OGJoined: December 2008Reppin: Fire and SmokePosts: 44,603▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
do you expect marvel to lol?
I ain't really care, see my mind's elsewhere like, I ain't really here
29th July '09, 12:58 AM#23
Jack Man Everyday BlatantNever Been TimidJoined: December 2008Posts: 73▮
EliteGrimeKid said:
how can you say forget marvel, scorcher, etc. they are like our biggest chance.. do u expect people like terminator to hit mainstream and attract listeners worldwide
:lol: tru true no disrespect to terminator but he is actually crap, i cant imagine middle class white boys singing AND ITS T!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Having said that i love him.


Andre said:
do you expect marvel to lol?
to be fair, wear my own creps is catchy, has the makings of "commercial grime".

EDIT:

the other thing american hip hop artists have over gime artists is that they are more business minded and stick together, plus one could easily sell a mill in the US just aiming at the black population seeing as they make up about 12% of the US


Uncle Ruckus said:
Remember no matter how much money you have you will always be a N###a.
29th July '09, 12:59 AM#24
EliteGrimeKidI'm a man with a lot of Pride So it's standard I gotta typeJoined: March 2009Posts: 618▮
Andre said:
do you expect marvel to lol?
hmm probably not marvel but double s maybe, i mean in general people that can actually write good lyrics not shit like "beef to me is like having a cup of tea" or whatever he says lol
SOME MAN ARE QUOTING AGAIN, DONT REALISE WHAT THEY'RE POSTING AGAIN.
29th July '09, 01:01 AM#25
AndreGrime Forum OGJoined: December 2008Reppin: Fire and SmokePosts: 44,603▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
that track about shoes is shit
I ain't really care, see my mind's elsewhere like, I ain't really here
29th July '09, 01:03 AM#26
Jack Man Everyday BlatantNever Been TimidJoined: December 2008Posts: 73▮
Andre said:
that track about shoes is shit
If i'm honest its weak lyrically bt caught me in a different way. i find a lot of people on this forum will reject any tune made by a grime artist if its not particularly greaze or if its about swagger, come out of your box


Uncle Ruckus said:
Remember no matter how much money you have you will always be a N###a.
29th July '09, 01:05 AM#27
AndreGrime Forum OGJoined: December 2008Reppin: Fire and SmokePosts: 44,603▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
no i just actually dont like the track

its not hype its not an anthem
I ain't really care, see my mind's elsewhere like, I ain't really here
29th July '09, 01:10 AM#28
EliteGrimeKidI'm a man with a lot of Pride So it's standard I gotta typeJoined: March 2009Posts: 618▮
grimes not about lyrics? what comes out of the mcs mouth then?
SOME MAN ARE QUOTING AGAIN, DONT REALISE WHAT THEY'RE POSTING AGAIN.
29th July '09, 01:11 AM#29
Jack Man Everyday BlatantNever Been TimidJoined: December 2008Posts: 73▮
Grime is NOT about lyrics!!!

LOL @ not rating Terminator.

Goodz,
Kano
Ghetts,

i could go on but you do have a point, grime is either extremely lyrical or the opposite.

I have to be fair Terminator is one of the worst MCs ive ever heard but i always sing along to his lyrics


Uncle Ruckus said:
Remember no matter how much money you have you will always be a N###a.
29th July '09, 01:14 AM#30
EliteGrimeKidI'm a man with a lot of Pride So it's standard I gotta typeJoined: March 2009Posts: 618▮
Jack Man Everyday Blatant said:
Goodz,
Kano
Ghetts,

i could go on but you do have a point, grime is either extremely lyrical or the opposite.

I have to be fair Terminator is one of the worst MCs ive ever heard but i always sing along to his lyrics
yh thats my point, but these mcs that people like because they have catchy singalongs, etc. probably wont make it in the mainstream but the ones that are lyrical have a greater chance
SOME MAN ARE QUOTING AGAIN, DONT REALISE WHAT THEY'RE POSTING AGAIN.
29th July '09, 01:17 AM#31
Jack Man Everyday BlatantNever Been TimidJoined: December 2008Posts: 73▮
EliteGrimeKid said:
yh thats my point, but these mcs that people like because they have catchy singalongs, etc. probably wont make it in the mainstream but the ones that are lyrical have a greater chance
:lol: tbh its the other way around as mainstream is more catchy singalongs, but the thing is MCs like Tempz and Terminator who have catchy singalongs are usually too greaze 4 mainstream


Uncle Ruckus said:
Remember no matter how much money you have you will always be a N###a.
29th July '09, 01:21 AM#32
pcollinsI Type Posts On Spiderman RooftopsJoined: March 2008Posts: 419▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
only american guy ive heard of listening to grime was saying how he goes around his house spitting terminators lyrics, so dont ever say he hasnt got appeal!! for one thing hes slow so he is easy to pick up on, and for another thing...his lyrics are funny as fuck!!
29th July '09, 01:21 AM#33
EliteGrimeKidI'm a man with a lot of Pride So it's standard I gotta typeJoined: March 2009Posts: 618▮
Jack Man Everyday Blatant said:
:lol: tbh its the other way around as mainstream is more catchy singalongs, but the thing is MCs like Tempz and Terminator who have catchy singalongs are usually too greaze 4 mainstream
yh but in the US alot of the rappers in the mainstream are lyrical, eg. Kanye west, Ludacris, Jay Z, Eminem, the list goes on
SOME MAN ARE QUOTING AGAIN, DONT REALISE WHAT THEY'RE POSTING AGAIN.
29th July '09, 01:23 AM#34
spliffyGod Forgive Me If I Press EnterJoined: April 2008Reppin: EndzPosts: 1,527▮
EliteGrimeKid said:
how can you say forget marvel, scorcher, etc. they are like our biggest chance.. do u expect people like terminator to hit mainstream and attract listeners worldwide
Who gives a fuck, he's making music now without having to get a record deal to get it and he seems happy enough. And you've seen the shit scorcher has made to try and make it you really want him doing more of that under the banner of grime?

Chip diddy chips versus and its t... hmmm....

Power corrups; mainstream corrupts.

Stay in the underground.
Anytime you see me wearing a glove boy better know it's winter.
29th July '09, 01:25 AM#35
Pub GuyBoy Better PostJoined: January 2008Posts: 20▮
You have Soulja Boy moving units with rapping ability and lyrics worse than T's or even Discarda.

The bottom line is that America is bigger. Retrofreak pretty much summed it up.

The generation who are growing up on Giggs, Dizzee, Chippy, Tinchy, N-Dubz etc won't have the same attitude to genre as the people in their late teens/early 20's who make up a lot of grime's core audience right now. Grime will probably be a word used to describe a sub-genre of UK Rap, this is happening right now, that doesn't grime is dead but it does mean it's changing.
29th July '09, 01:28 AM#36
Jack Man Everyday BlatantNever Been TimidJoined: December 2008Posts: 73▮
EliteGrimeKid said:
yh but in the US alot of the rappers in the mainstream are lyrical, eg. Kanye west, Ludacris, Jay Z, Eminem, the list goes on
but listen to their tunes that sell more, they water down their lyrical ability in favour of a catchy hook, and :lol: at Luda being lyrical, ill check tht 1 out still.


Uncle Ruckus said:
Remember no matter how much money you have you will always be a N###a.
29th July '09, 01:30 AM#37
EliteGrimeKidI'm a man with a lot of Pride So it's standard I gotta typeJoined: March 2009Posts: 618▮
how is ludacris not lyrical?
SOME MAN ARE QUOTING AGAIN, DONT REALISE WHAT THEY'RE POSTING AGAIN.
29th July '09, 01:30 AM#38
Burden DurdenGrime Forum DonJoined: December 2008Posts: 8,521
commercial clubs play HipHop all the time, you hardly ever hear one grime tune in these same clubs
I'm tryna turn heroin to grands, dats B 2 K, like Omarion and J Boog
29th July '09, 01:32 AM#39
EliteGrimeKidI'm a man with a lot of Pride So it's standard I gotta typeJoined: March 2009Posts: 618▮
tbh i dont really want grime to go mainsteam i like it how it is
SOME MAN ARE QUOTING AGAIN, DONT REALISE WHAT THEY'RE POSTING AGAIN.
29th July '09, 01:34 AM#40
Jack Man Everyday BlatantNever Been TimidJoined: December 2008Posts: 73▮
EliteGrimeKid said:
tbh i dont really want grime to go mainsteam i like it how it is
ye bt its inevitable MCs need Ps.


Uncle Ruckus said:
Remember no matter how much money you have you will always be a N###a.

See the saved original on the Wayback Machine