📖 Grimepedia
An archive of grimeforum.com, 2007–2022. Read-only.
Archive › Grime Discussion

Is Grime to Inclusive??

27th May '09, 11:13 AM#1
LC1I Was Like You Rudeboy I Had No Rep To GiiiiivveJoined: June 2008Posts: 1,352▮
Is it me or should people start celebrating grime and the music with its influence alot more. On here the attitude seems to be one that if the track ain't by one of a core group of people and doesn't include a certain synth or bass then its a shit tune or the artist has sold out!

I mean look at kano.. yes he made some more commercial music but still made 140 grime st with some hip hop influenced grime yet people ruined him and said it was shit reh reh. durrty goodz makes dubstep, hip hop and ragga influenced grime and althouh he gfets alot more slack he isn't a straight grime artist but who is?? alot of mc's have a dance/garage/hip hop influence in their music and in all fairness grime is a hybrid of all of those plus more so if grime is some bastard child of other genres should we be so harsh in ruining their music when these influences are more pronounced i nsome songs.

I am one thst only really appreciates proper 02-03 minimal bassy grime and have not got much time for alot of new stuff and new mc's but is it fair??

look at dubstep as a prime example..... no one can say that that genre can be defined as a whole either yet new influences and people's take on it are celebrated. i mean look at skream and benga..... then look at mala and then caspa's big basslines or burial's music and try and see similarities in their music. bare boys i know insist burial is two step.
same goes fir starkey and rustie and the whole wonky thing.. it has alot of hip hop influences yet the dubstep followers welcome people like this into their scene and maybe as a result this is why dubstep's creativity is alot as these new people will continue to influence the scene to keep pushing the sound.

as a result people talk up dubstep as a scene that is growing stronger and wider yet people look at grime as musically and creatively dying out. so should people start laying off kano, chipmunk tynchy stryfder and embrace them as to most peoole they represent grime and can only push the name wider, plus it shows grime artists are getting success and others can then follow?????

discuss.

plus i am playing devils advocate here abit still
27th May '09, 11:38 AM#2
jdawg19Any GuyJoined: March 2009Posts: 3▮
too Exclusive*
27th May '09, 11:44 AM#3
PredSuper ModThe nation's favourite modJoined: January 2008Reppin: BasingstokePosts: 12,309▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Dubstep is still a unique sound, whereas Grime is turning into Hip Hop. It's lost all 8 Bar influence and it's lost the minimal sound that is perfect for live shows and mixing. You could blame people not buying it. They have to make money somehow.

Dubstep branches out and people have different interpretations of it, but it's not an MC led scene. It's an instrumental scene, and it grows because people buy it.
http://mypsn.eu.playstation.com/psn/profile/BigPred.png
(Might have to refresh it)
I don't care what she likes, man can't say I'm not top 10 in England, bury anybody disagreeing in an instant, stageshow duppy or sunday Rinse them!
27th May '09, 12:27 PM#4
RetrofreakSuper ModRadio is dead... Music lives on in the minds of the free!!Posts: 13,831▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Too Obtrusive.
The Victorious Warrior First Wins Then Seeks Battle
The Defeated Warrior First Battles Then Seeks Victory
- Sun Tzu
27th May '09, 12:35 PM#5
'nuum generalGrime Forum OGJoined: January 2006Reppin: HullPosts: 17,188▮
if its good music I listen to it, if its shit I don't. Nowadays most stuff seems to fall into the latter. Comparing it to dubstep is not really possible as dubstep has tunes influenced by all sorts of music. When have you ever heard a techno or breaks influenced grime tune?
The Myth
27th May '09, 12:41 PM#6
The DonGrime Forum RegularJoined: July 2008Reppin: Uxbridge roadPosts: 7,369▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
That's a lot of text, is this just another recycled paragraph about what's wrong with grime?
27th May '09, 12:46 PM#7
LC1I Was Like You Rudeboy I Had No Rep To GiiiiivveJoined: June 2008Posts: 1,352▮
The Don said:
That's a lot of text, is this just another recycled paragraph about what's wrong with grime?
not at all....... its basically why don't the grime scene welcome outside influences into the scene in the way genres like dubstep do and is it one of the reasons for the opinion that grime is dying which is bullshit anyway.
but i find it weird hoW EXCLUSIVE (LOL) grime is
27th May '09, 12:52 PM#8
RetrofreakSuper ModRadio is dead... Music lives on in the minds of the free!!Posts: 13,831▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
LC1 said:
not at all....... its basically why don't the grime scene welcome outside influences into the scene in the way genres like dubstep do and is it one of the reasons for the opinion that grime is dying which is bullshit anyway.
but i find it weird hoW EXCLUSIVE (LOL) grime is
It's flawed, by it's insular design...Exciting at times, but musically limited.

I cant see it lasting for long as we know it, but can see it being a style underneath a bigger Genre.
The Victorious Warrior First Wins Then Seeks Battle
The Defeated Warrior First Battles Then Seeks Victory
- Sun Tzu
27th May '09, 12:57 PM#9
RevolutionMy Fingers Type Like They're Powered MechanicallyJoined: April 2009Posts: 2,903▮
Retrofreak said:
It's flawed, by it's insular design...Exciting at times, but musically limited.

I cant see it lasting for long as we know it, but can see it being a style underneath a bigger Genre.
mmmm... i hear dat... but what bigger genre?
The Revolution is coming...
27th May '09, 12:59 PM#10
RetrofreakSuper ModRadio is dead... Music lives on in the minds of the free!!Posts: 13,831▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Revolution said:
mmmm... i hear dat... but what bigger genre?
Hip Hop
The Victorious Warrior First Wins Then Seeks Battle
The Defeated Warrior First Battles Then Seeks Victory
- Sun Tzu
27th May '09, 12:59 PM#11
LC1I Was Like You Rudeboy I Had No Rep To GiiiiivveJoined: June 2008Posts: 1,352▮
Pred said:
Dubstep is still a unique sound, whereas Grime is turning into Hip Hop. It's lost all 8 Bar influence and it's lost the minimal sound that is perfect for live shows and mixing. You could blame people not buying it. They have to make money somehow.

Dubstep branches out and people have different interpretations of it, but it's not an MC led scene. It's an instrumental scene, and it grows because people buy it.
yeh true but can't this be the case for grime??

I mean alot of tunes from the likes of ghetto ansd cscorcher taht are slagged off for bein shit have alot of grime influences within them from the hi hats to the bpm plus the style of spittin is crucial to a grime sound. alot of these artists have a unique grime influence in their songs so should we accept it under the grime umbrella??

stsrkey and rustie make tracks incredibly hip hop sounding yet people will talk them as part of the dubstep scene. when chase ansd status made some dubstep tracks and that kano joint on their albu mdid people within d n b ridicule them?????
27th May '09, 01:00 PM#12
LC1I Was Like You Rudeboy I Had No Rep To GiiiiivveJoined: June 2008Posts: 1,352▮
Hip Hop


hopefully garage and minimal house
27th May '09, 01:02 PM#13
RevolutionMy Fingers Type Like They're Powered MechanicallyJoined: April 2009Posts: 2,903▮
Hip Hop

it wud b shit if dis happens... so u rekon grime will fundementally lose its identity?
The Revolution is coming...
27th May '09, 01:03 PM#14
RetrofreakSuper ModRadio is dead... Music lives on in the minds of the free!!Posts: 13,831▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
LC1 said:
hopefully garage and minimal house
Right now It's got more in common with Hip Hop than House, Garage and Ragga combined imo.
The Victorious Warrior First Wins Then Seeks Battle
The Defeated Warrior First Battles Then Seeks Victory
- Sun Tzu
27th May '09, 01:04 PM#15
RevolutionMy Fingers Type Like They're Powered MechanicallyJoined: April 2009Posts: 2,903▮
Retrofreak said:
Right now It's got more in common with Hip Hop than House, Garage and Ragga combined imo.
Ye...Tru dat
The Revolution is coming...
27th May '09, 01:05 PM#16
LC1I Was Like You Rudeboy I Had No Rep To GiiiiivveJoined: June 2008Posts: 1,352▮
Retrofreak said:
Right now It's got more in common with Hip Hop than House, Garage and Ragga combined imo.
i know thats why i actually cared about grime back in 03 when the minimal dance elements were still strong
27th May '09, 01:05 PM#17
PredSuper ModThe nation's favourite modJoined: January 2008Reppin: BasingstokePosts: 12,309▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Retrofreak said:
right now it's got more in common with hip hop than house, garage and ragga combined imo.
qft.
http://mypsn.eu.playstation.com/psn/profile/BigPred.png
(Might have to refresh it)
I don't care what she likes, man can't say I'm not top 10 in England, bury anybody disagreeing in an instant, stageshow duppy or sunday Rinse them!
27th May '09, 01:05 PM#18
RetrofreakSuper ModRadio is dead... Music lives on in the minds of the free!!Posts: 13,831▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Revolution said:
it wud b shit if dis happens... so u rekon grime will fundementally lose its identity?
NO.

Crunk, Miami Bass, Electro are all under Hip Hop with their identities intact.


Put it this way, when I put Ghetto and Dot's CD's in iTunes I don't file them under Garage. lol
The Victorious Warrior First Wins Then Seeks Battle
The Defeated Warrior First Battles Then Seeks Victory
- Sun Tzu
27th May '09, 01:06 PM#19
'nuum generalGrime Forum OGJoined: January 2006Reppin: HullPosts: 17,188▮
Retrofreak said:
Right now It's got more in common with Hip Hop than House, Garage and Ragga combined imo.
with a weighting towards hip hop & this will continue to be the case as its what most of the producers listen to
The Myth
27th May '09, 01:07 PM#20
RevolutionMy Fingers Type Like They're Powered MechanicallyJoined: April 2009Posts: 2,903▮
Retrofreak said:
NO.

Crunk, Miami Bass, Electro are all under Hip Hop with their identities intact.


Put it this way, when I put Ghetto and Dot's CD's in iTunes I don't file them under Garage. lol
okay... ye i get u... so grime's a sub genre of the bigger genre hip hop
The Revolution is coming...
27th May '09, 01:26 PM#21
PredSuper ModThe nation's favourite modJoined: January 2008Reppin: BasingstokePosts: 12,309▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Could this work in Grime's favour? If the scene, and not just people on the forum, accepted the association with Hip Hop, do you think it could give it a new lease of life? It would certainly make it more accessible.

Although you can't just walk into someone's New York office and say "Yo, we're officially Hip Hop now."
http://mypsn.eu.playstation.com/psn/profile/BigPred.png
(Might have to refresh it)
I don't care what she likes, man can't say I'm not top 10 in England, bury anybody disagreeing in an instant, stageshow duppy or sunday Rinse them!
27th May '09, 01:34 PM#22
RetrofreakSuper ModRadio is dead... Music lives on in the minds of the free!!Posts: 13,831▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Pred said:
Could this work in Grime's favour? If the scene, and not just people on the forum, accepted the association with Hip Hop, do you think it could give it a new lease of life? It would certainly make it more accessible.

Although you can't just walk into someone's New York office and say "Yo, we're officially Hip Hop now."
GF mans are more shook of Hip Hop than any other Genre why?

Cause we know in are hearts that it's our take on Hip Hop.

I think we should stop over obsessing on what is/isnt Grime and just make good music.

I think if we accepted this we'd have a stronger more diverse UK rap scene that encompassed "Road rap" etc.

It's a natural progression, evolution and happening any way lol
The Victorious Warrior First Wins Then Seeks Battle
The Defeated Warrior First Battles Then Seeks Victory
- Sun Tzu
27th May '09, 01:36 PM#23
THOR!Your Posts Sound Out Of Date And Expired I Check My CP, Got Bare AdmiresPosts: 4,942▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Retrofreak said:
GF mans are more shook of Hip Hop than any other Genre why?

Cause we know in are hearts that it's our take on Hip Hop.

I think we should stop over obsessing on what is/isnt Grime and just make good music.

I think if we accepted this we'd have a stronger more diverse UK rap scene that encompassed "Road rap" etc.

It's a natural progression, evolution and happening any way lol
True.
Fear of the name only increases fear of the thing itself
Fear my banhammer!
27th May '09, 02:42 PM#24
The DonGrime Forum RegularJoined: July 2008Reppin: Uxbridge roadPosts: 7,369▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Good points in the thread but I can 100% see why GF guys are 'shook' of Hip Hop lol.

If there's widespread acceptance of Hip Hops influence, the already decreasing grime foundations of minimalism, one line flows, and radio will continue to decline, like they're not enough of a rarity already. Imo this will do the opposite of Pred's hope for more (I assume) musical variation and experimentation, the acceptance of this will make nearly everyone in the scene make the most generic sounding Hip Hop possible judging on the Hip Hop we've actually been presented with from Grime artists so far.

Grime's critical state is over exaggerated imo, there's more variation between Tempz, Rotten, Wiley, Doogz and especially Dizzee (albeit in his case as a result of him not watching being pigeon holed; but not every artist is that smart) than there would be if everyone saw it as their right to officially make Hip Hop.
27th May '09, 02:47 PM#25
PredSuper ModThe nation's favourite modJoined: January 2008Reppin: BasingstokePosts: 12,309▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Retrofreak said:
GF mans are more shook of Hip Hop than any other Genre why?

Cause we know in are hearts that it's our take on Hip Hop.

I think we should stop over obsessing on what is/isnt Grime and just make good music.

I think if we accepted this we'd have a stronger more diverse UK rap scene that encompassed "Road rap" etc.

It's a natural progression, evolution and happening any way lol
I never considered early Grime as a form of Hip Hop, as I saw it as a genre that came from Garage. Despite it being Hip Hop influenced if you go back, it was far away from Hip Hop to be something different. But yes, now it has some full circle.

But that raises another question. Let's take Noc as an example. The majority of his production from Back In A Big Way to Don't Phone Me is obviously considered Grime. But when you say Grime is a sub-genre of Hip Hop, Don't Phone Me becomes Hip Hop. But Hip Hop is the American culture. To some it might seems like a 'six of one and half a dozen of the other' thing but the genre "rap" sits better with me, as rap as an artform goes back further than Hip Hop (back to Jamaica). But not everyone would agree with that definition, so it leads onto the argument of the definition. Which will never be finished.
http://mypsn.eu.playstation.com/psn/profile/BigPred.png
(Might have to refresh it)
I don't care what she likes, man can't say I'm not top 10 in England, bury anybody disagreeing in an instant, stageshow duppy or sunday Rinse them!
27th May '09, 02:51 PM#26
RetrofreakSuper ModRadio is dead... Music lives on in the minds of the free!!Posts: 13,831▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
The Don said:
Good points in the thread but I can 100% see why GF guys are 'shook' of Hip Hop lol.

If there's widespread acceptance of Hip Hops influence, the already decreasing grime foundations of minimalism, one line flows, and radio will continue to decline, like they're not enough of a rarity already. Imo this will do the opposite of Pred's hope for more (I assume) musical variation and experimentation, the acceptance of this will make nearly everyone in the scene make the most generic sounding Hip Hop possible judging on the Hip Hop we've actually been presented with from Grime artists so far.

Grime's critical state is over exaggerated imo, there's more variation between Tempz, Rotten, Wiley, Doogz and especially Dizzee (albeit in his case as a result of him not watching being pigeon holed; but not every artist is that smart) than there would be if everyone saw it as their right to officially make Hip Hop.
All the styles of which you speak, "Hip Hop" already does as it's versatile by design.

Grime will always be a style, but I feel it's too restrictive to become a full a genre.

Sounds come in and out of fashion and the music should be able to adapt and reflect that.

Being stuck within a set tempo range with a limited sound set, rapping about the same stuff is a fools paradise imo.
The Victorious Warrior First Wins Then Seeks Battle
The Defeated Warrior First Battles Then Seeks Victory
- Sun Tzu
27th May '09, 02:57 PM#27
slu-wasteguyGrime Forum OGJoined: March 2008Posts: 19,161▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Hip Hop

oh lord god no!
27th May '09, 03:03 PM#28
RetrofreakSuper ModRadio is dead... Music lives on in the minds of the free!!Posts: 13,831▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Pred said:
I never considered early Grime as a form of Hip Hop, as I saw it as a genre that came from Garage. Despite it being Hip Hop influenced if you go back, it was far away from Hip Hop to be something different. But yes, now it has some full circle.

But that raises another question. Let's take Noc as an example. The majority of his production from Back In A Big Way to Don't Phone Me is obviously considered Grime. But when you say Grime is a sub-genre of Hip Hop, Don't Phone Me becomes Hip Hop. But Hip Hop is the American culture. To some it might seems like a 'six of one and half a dozen of the other' thing but the genre "rap" sits better with me, as rap as an artform goes back further than Hip Hop (back to Jamaica). But not everyone would agree with that definition, so it leads onto the argument of the definition. Which will never be finished.
Grime's always had a Hip Hop element in it, just more of the Jamaican side of things tbh.

MC's were spitting on all sorts before Garage so it was just a means to an end at that time.

Rap/Hip Hop doesn't frighten me as I just except it, move on, innovate and enjoy the music.

Trying to sweep Hip Hop under the rug and pass Timbaland's influence's off as our own will only end in tears later.

Grime is a time and a culture, that has potential to become the "New UK Rap"
The Victorious Warrior First Wins Then Seeks Battle
The Defeated Warrior First Battles Then Seeks Victory
- Sun Tzu
27th May '09, 03:07 PM#29
RetrofreakSuper ModRadio is dead... Music lives on in the minds of the free!!Posts: 13,831▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
oh lord god no!

Why so shook?
The Victorious Warrior First Wins Then Seeks Battle
The Defeated Warrior First Battles Then Seeks Victory
- Sun Tzu
27th May '09, 03:21 PM#30
T.BAwaiting E-mail ConfirmationJoined: March 2009Reppin: DagenhamPosts: 1,005▮
Pred said:
Dubstep is still a unique sound, whereas Grime is turning into Hip Hop. It's lost all 8 Bar influence and it's lost the minimal sound that is perfect for live shows and mixing. You could blame people not buying it. They have to make money somehow.

Dubstep branches out and people have different interpretations of it, but it's not an MC led scene. It's an instrumental scene, and it grows because people buy it.
i couldn't have displayed it more simple myself.
go to http://tinyurl.com/tbartist for quality music
27th May '09, 03:31 PM#31
PredSuper ModThe nation's favourite modJoined: January 2008Reppin: BasingstokePosts: 12,309▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Retrofreak said:
Grime's always had a Hip Hop element in it, just more of the Jamaican side of things tbh.

MC's were spitting on all sorts before Garage so it was just a means to an end at that time.

Rap/Hip Hop doesn't frighten me as I just except it, move on, innovate and enjoy the music.

Trying to sweep Hip Hop under the rug and pass Timbaland's influence's off as our own will only end in tears later.

Grime is a time and a culture, that has potential to become the "New UK Rap"
I wouldn't say it's sweeping Timb's influence under the rug, it'd be a lie to do that. But it's just the way I visualise things. For me it's like:


Rap
US Hip Hop
Crunk (etc)

Grime

Electronic
House
Dubstep
UK Garage

2-step
4x4



Of course that's simplfied and things take influence from other genres etc etc, but as it stands today, I think it's fair to say that Grime is a form of rap music.
http://mypsn.eu.playstation.com/psn/profile/BigPred.png
(Might have to refresh it)
I don't care what she likes, man can't say I'm not top 10 in England, bury anybody disagreeing in an instant, stageshow duppy or sunday Rinse them!
27th May '09, 03:59 PM#32
RetrofreakSuper ModRadio is dead... Music lives on in the minds of the free!!Posts: 13,831▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Pred said:
I wouldn't say it's sweeping Timb's influence under the rug, it'd be a lie to do that. But it's just the way I visualise things. For me it's like:


Rap
US Hip Hop
Crunk (etc)

Grime

Electronic
House
Dubstep
UK Garage

2-step
4x4



Of course that's simplfied and things take influence from other genres etc etc, but as it stands today, I think it's fair to say that Grime is a form of rap music.
Yeah true, but the fact that we:

1. keep on debating the identity of Grime
2. Discuss US Rap artists/Producers on this forum so much.
3. Try to emulate the slang, musical trends and clothing etc.

Prove that were shook of Hip Hop, cause Grime is a sub-genre of it.
The Victorious Warrior First Wins Then Seeks Battle
The Defeated Warrior First Battles Then Seeks Victory
- Sun Tzu
27th May '09, 04:17 PM#33
PredSuper ModThe nation's favourite modJoined: January 2008Reppin: BasingstokePosts: 12,309▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Retrofreak said:
Yeah true, but the fact that we:

1. keep on debating the identity of Grime
2. Discuss US Rap artists/Producers on this forum so much.
3. Try to emulate the slang, musical trends and clothing etc.

Prove that were shook of Hip Hop, cause Grime is a sub-genre of it.
...and that's the sad reality of it. As long as people continue to follow America (stop watching Smack DVD!) Grime will effectively be a sub-culture of Hip Hop.

Although I don't listen to anyone who goes on about swagger or says "darg".
inb4 BothWordsAreUsedIn1SentenceAsAPseudoHumourousReply
But that is bigger than Grime, and bigger than music altogether.
http://mypsn.eu.playstation.com/psn/profile/BigPred.png
(Might have to refresh it)
I don't care what she likes, man can't say I'm not top 10 in England, bury anybody disagreeing in an instant, stageshow duppy or sunday Rinse them!
27th May '09, 04:26 PM#34
GrimesSuper ModI will continue with my wicked waysiDonateJoined: January 2008Reppin: Y'all need mePosts: 39,157▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
darg swagger
27th May '09, 04:30 PM#35
slu-wasteguyGrime Forum OGJoined: March 2008Posts: 19,161▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Why so shook?

cos im a purist! thats why lol
27th May '09, 05:11 PM#36
THOR!Your Posts Sound Out Of Date And Expired I Check My CP, Got Bare AdmiresPosts: 4,942▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
slu-wasteguy said:
cos im a purist! thats why lol
No such thing, grime isn't pure.

Neither is Hip Hop for the record.
Fear my banhammer!
27th May '09, 05:21 PM#37
'nuum generalGrime Forum OGJoined: January 2006Reppin: HullPosts: 17,188▮
I think this thread has derailed into "what is grime, I don't want it to be hip hop" again.

It was originally about why wider influences have not come into the music as with other genres (notably dubstep)
The Myth
27th May '09, 05:24 PM#38
RevolutionMy Fingers Type Like They're Powered MechanicallyJoined: April 2009Posts: 2,903▮
THOR! said:
No such thing, grime isn't pure.

Neither is Hip Hop for the record.
Tru dat... we shud stop tryin 2 label grime dis surely restricts da music
The Revolution is coming...
27th May '09, 06:07 PM#39
JayHibernatingiSupportJoined: February 2009Posts: 7,717▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
'nuum general said:
It was originally about why wider influences have not come into the music as with other genres (notably dubstep)
Getting back to this. Most guys past the age of 18 don't wanna hear abotu which 16 year old is the hardest, which is what 90% of the stuff I hear these days is about.
27th May '09, 07:27 PM#40
The DonGrime Forum RegularJoined: July 2008Reppin: Uxbridge roadPosts: 7,369▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Jay said:
Getting back to this. Most guys past the age of 18 don't wanna hear abotu which 16 year old is the hardest, which is what 90% of the stuff I hear these days is about.
This. If it does continue to follow Hip Hop in the way it is, with emphasis being placed on content instead of reload bars, it'll suffer, because there's only so many "I'm sick like I need a doctor" bars you can fit into a 16 without getting fucking boring.

See the saved original on the Wayback Machine