Shanger said:
i think ppl like ghetto, wiley, scorcher (when hes not being gay), dot rotten, goodz are up there. all of whom can hav good rhyme schemes, ride the beat etc.
I agree to a point; Dot, Ghetts and Wiley especially. Even Wretch 32 is another who I considered a great artist, even though I don't consider him grime. I think those guys are quality artists that are great spitters have put out quality releases. I know that Wiley and Ghetto have plenty fans stateside and I've put many guys onto them.
The thing that makes me hesitant to really compare Grime MCs as whole in comparison to our US artists, and reasonably so, is catalog. All of the guys I listed are either a combination of: a) top lyricism, b) have several acclaimed releases to their credit c) top song crafters. Let's go back to the guys mentioned in this thread Nas has put out 10 albums, 7 of which being quality listens, including Illmatic and Stillmatic - two of the best hip-hop albums of all-time. I think it's fair for some people to be skeptical to compare that resume to an artist with only two mixtapes to his name unless they make truly transcendent music.
I cannot say with a straight face that "Letter 2 Titch" is a better song than "I Gave You Power", "Nas Is Like", "If I Ruled the World...", etc. Please believe that it's just more than just the supposed allure of having an American accent.
We have a lot of artists here that drop a hot couple mixtapes and show a lot of talent, only to level off and put out a poor release if they even get the opportunity to drop an album.
Then again, part of my hesitance stems from why grime is different from rap/hip-hop. Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong, but grime is still a young scene and doesn't get regular album releases from artists on the whole. The scene lacks organization.
In short, a handful of grime guys are really top artists regardless of genre, but I simply do not agree with really comparing artists to legends when that current artist does not really have much to compare. While an top MC from your ends can most likely spit better and Wayne, Ross, 50 and Souljah Boy, I would just slooooow down with saying they are loads better than an Eminem or Nas. It's like comparing Michael Jordan to LeBron James in a way. Yeah, while you can make such an argument you simply won't have much of a leg to stand on.*
* = until he has the type of season he's having right now.
Good discussion, though.