For
Arsenal manager Arsene Wenger has backed Manuel Almunia as the best possible solution to England's goalkeeping problems.
Having never represented the Spanish national team, Almunia has long been mooted as a possible candidate to be England's number one, should he take up British citizenship through his English wife.
"I believe he is not only good enough, but he is the best," stated Wenger.
"There are international rules which have to be respected, but if it is possible legally, why not?
"Then it is more a choice left to the English Football Association or to Manuel Almunia's desire."
Wenger may well be in favour, but he admits that he is unsure whether either party would actually be willing to agree to Almunia's inclusion.
"It is down to what you expect morally and mentally from a national team," he added.
"On the English side, for the national team, it is not so much a problem because if the guy decides to become English, he has had to observe and respect the rules like anybody else.
"Why should he then not be qualified to play for the national team?
"It is more a moral problem maybe for Manuel Almunia, because does he consider he has a chance to play in the Spanish national team or not?"
Against
Arsenal goalkeeper Manuel Almunia completes five years' residency in England this summer and having not represented his native Spain, he would be eligible for England selection.
Most major nations at Euro 2008 fielded a foreign-born player, with winners Spain themselves featuring Brazilian-born midfielder Marcos Senna, who played a key role in their success.
However, Redknapp feels that if Almunia were to play for England it would encourage more foreign players to come to the Premier League.
And the Spurs boss reckons that would not only block the way for emerging domestic players to represent their country but also make it difficult for them to establish themselves as regulars for their club.
"I think if players come and play for an English club and they're here for five years, I don't see how they should play for England," he told Sky Sports News.
Difficult
"That's my view and nothing will change my opinion on that one.
"It's difficult enough for home-grown players to get in the Premier League at the moment.
"We've got lots of foreign players here now but if we start letting people come here for five years and start playing for England then we could end up with a team of foreign players in a few years, and that's something I wouldn't want to see.
"If they're good enough, they should play for their own country. I don't see how they should qualify to play for England."
Discuss.
All views are welcome.
Even Bigotry.
Arsenal manager Arsene Wenger has backed Manuel Almunia as the best possible solution to England's goalkeeping problems.
Having never represented the Spanish national team, Almunia has long been mooted as a possible candidate to be England's number one, should he take up British citizenship through his English wife.
"I believe he is not only good enough, but he is the best," stated Wenger.
"There are international rules which have to be respected, but if it is possible legally, why not?
"Then it is more a choice left to the English Football Association or to Manuel Almunia's desire."
Wenger may well be in favour, but he admits that he is unsure whether either party would actually be willing to agree to Almunia's inclusion.
"It is down to what you expect morally and mentally from a national team," he added.
"On the English side, for the national team, it is not so much a problem because if the guy decides to become English, he has had to observe and respect the rules like anybody else.
"Why should he then not be qualified to play for the national team?
"It is more a moral problem maybe for Manuel Almunia, because does he consider he has a chance to play in the Spanish national team or not?"
Against
Arsenal goalkeeper Manuel Almunia completes five years' residency in England this summer and having not represented his native Spain, he would be eligible for England selection.
Most major nations at Euro 2008 fielded a foreign-born player, with winners Spain themselves featuring Brazilian-born midfielder Marcos Senna, who played a key role in their success.
However, Redknapp feels that if Almunia were to play for England it would encourage more foreign players to come to the Premier League.
And the Spurs boss reckons that would not only block the way for emerging domestic players to represent their country but also make it difficult for them to establish themselves as regulars for their club.
"I think if players come and play for an English club and they're here for five years, I don't see how they should play for England," he told Sky Sports News.
Difficult
"That's my view and nothing will change my opinion on that one.
"It's difficult enough for home-grown players to get in the Premier League at the moment.
"We've got lots of foreign players here now but if we start letting people come here for five years and start playing for England then we could end up with a team of foreign players in a few years, and that's something I wouldn't want to see.
"If they're good enough, they should play for their own country. I don't see how they should qualify to play for England."
Discuss.
All views are welcome.
Even Bigotry.


