📖 Grimepedia
An archive of grimeforum.com, 2007–2022. Read-only.
Archive › Sports

LOL @ Carragher

5th September '08, 07:47 PM#41
The MessiahSuper ModThe Grime Forum DoctorReppin: The EndsPosts: 19,250▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Grimes said:
obviously pepe Reina is great but lets be real, he isn't known for his shot stopping ability. Liverpool have only been playing two holding midfielders for the second half of last season. while are defensive record has been great for the last 3 seasons
You ignored both mine and quality's point about Liverpool playing more defensive football than other teams. Additionally you can't deny that Reina is a very good goalkeeper who contributed significantly more to those defensive stats than Carragher did.
SKENGMAN MODE said:
your not real life... just something of the internet
5th September '08, 07:50 PM#42
GrimesSuper ModI will continue with my wicked waysiDonateJoined: January 2008Reppin: Y'all need mePosts: 39,157▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
quality said:
Regardless of preference, players like Woodgate, Campbell and King are much more comfortable on the ball. That counts for a lot at international level, not so much in the Premiership.
LOL seen. defenders like Claudio Gentile. just off the top of my head. who played great internationally and weren't the most comfortable on the ball.

Any way isn't like Carragher can't kick the ball.
5th September '08, 07:53 PM#43
HijFounderGrime Forum ManagerReppin: London, United Kingdom, UPosts: 58,371▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
The Messiah said:
Again disagree. Was Carragher ever better than Rio Ferdinand, John Terry and pre-2005 Sol Campbell? No.
.

What the fuck? I quite clearly admitted John Terry is probably a better defender.

Im arguing that Carragher should have been 3rd pick regardless of the other dross that was around, due to his form in England and Europe at the time.

So if Ferdinand or Terry took a knock, Carragher should have stepped into the central berth, this never happened and this is where mine, and probably Carraghers qualms come into play.
Jack 1017 said:
Suarez is probably the best player in the world
5th September '08, 07:54 PM#44
GrimesSuper ModI will continue with my wicked waysiDonateJoined: January 2008Reppin: Y'all need mePosts: 39,157▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
The Messiah said:
You ignored both mine and quality's point about Liverpool playing more defensive football than other teams. Additionally you can't deny that Reina is a very good goalkeeper who contributed significantly more to those defensive stats than Carragher did.
i answered your point. liverpool have only been playing with two holding midfielders for the second half of last season.

Arbeloa ,Finnan, Aurelio and now Dossena all come forth and help attack. Liverpool have a great defensive base, but we are no means just defensive, we scored the most goals in all competitions last season.
5th September '08, 07:54 PM#45
HijFounderGrime Forum ManagerReppin: London, United Kingdom, UPosts: 58,371▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
The Messiah said:
Additionally you can't deny that Reina is a very good goalkeeper who contributed significantly more to those defensive stats than Carragher did.
All respect due, everyone goes on about how Reina is a shit keeper, not that I agree of course.
Jack 1017 said:
Suarez is probably the best player in the world
5th September '08, 07:55 PM#46
The MessiahSuper ModThe Grime Forum DoctorReppin: The EndsPosts: 19,250▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
This argument is going into minutiae and missing the overall point.

With regards to Wes Brown, Richards, Woodgate, Campbell and King - they were more than capable of getting England through that group with both Terry and Rio injured. Meaning that carrager not being in the england squad wasn't a factor at all in England getting knocked out. Deep down you know this so we can move on?
SKENGMAN MODE said:
your not real life... just something of the internet
5th September '08, 07:56 PM#47
6Grime Forum EliteiDonateJoined: April 2008Posts: 11,231▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
quality said:
Altho past England manager's haven't been massively successful (with the exception of Eriksson, who was reasonably successful), they must have seen a reason for not starting Carragher. The reason was Campbell and Ferdinand were always better, then Terry came along. And was better.
Back in those days, they did deserve to be in ahead of Carragher, but Carragher has improved loads since then, and in the season when he peaked, Terry did as well, but he got hyped about more because he was playing for the Champions at the time, so Carragher was overlooked.
5th September '08, 07:56 PM#48
qualityGrime Forum EliteJoined: March 2008Posts: 10,419▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Grimes said:
LOL seen. defenders like Claudio Gentile. just off the top of my head. who played great internationally and weren't the most comfortable on the ball.

Any way isn't like Carragher can't kick the ball.
Football has changed since the days of Gentile and Terry Butcher. Technique has become far more important. Spain and Italy aren't big physical teams, they've won the last two tournaments.

Look at Portugal - Carvalho and Pepe. Spain - Marchena and Puyol (to an extent). France - Thuram and Gallas. It's not the rule (Bouhlarouz and Matteratzi come to mind) but I'd say it's common thinking in international football.

Carragher can kick a ball obviously, but being completely comfortable with it is another thing.
Stepper said:
Vertogen>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Verms

Lennon>>>>>>>>>>>>>Theo
5th September '08, 07:57 PM#49
adidasgrandadGrime Forum OGiDonateJoined: January 2008Posts: 18,968▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
lol bad man carragher...

anyone remember when he threw the coin back into the crowd?wanker
smokey joe - "Mik looks likes a turtle"
5th September '08, 07:58 PM#50
GrimesSuper ModI will continue with my wicked waysiDonateJoined: January 2008Reppin: Y'all need mePosts: 39,157▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
no i won't accept that reina contributes significantly more than carragher did either. Reina hasn't got a particularly high shot to goal ratio with Cech,Almunia and Van de Sar, Friedel, and Tim Howard having bigger shot to goals ratio than Reina.
5th September '08, 07:59 PM#51
HijFounderGrime Forum ManagerReppin: London, United Kingdom, UPosts: 58,371▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
The Messiah said:
This argument is going into minutiae and missing the overall point.

With regards to Wes Brown, Richards, Woodgate, Campbell and King - they were more than capable of getting England through that group with both Terry and Rio injured. Meaning that carrager not being in the england squad wasn't a factor at all in England getting knocked out. Deep down you know this so we can move on?
Now your inferring that we believe Carragher was the reason England got knocked out?

Beggars belief now mate.
Jack 1017 said:
Suarez is probably the best player in the world
5th September '08, 08:00 PM#52
HijFounderGrime Forum ManagerReppin: London, United Kingdom, UPosts: 58,371▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
adidasgrandad said:
lol bad man carragher...

anyone remember when he threw the coin back into the crowd?wanker
Don't chuck one at him then.

He's Scouse, He's Sound, He'll Twat You With A Pound, Carragher!
Jack 1017 said:
Suarez is probably the best player in the world
5th September '08, 08:00 PM#53
The MessiahSuper ModThe Grime Forum DoctorReppin: The EndsPosts: 19,250▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Hij said:
What the fuck? I quite clearly admitted John Terry is probably a better defender.

Im arguing that Carragher should have been 3rd pick regardless of the other dross that was around, due to his form in England and Europe at the time.

So if Ferdinand or Terry took a knock, Carragher should have stepped into the central berth, this never happened and this is where mine, and probably Carraghers qualms come into play.
Like i said, when is an England squad ever truly chosen on form? Campbell was still performing well at the time, had much more international experience and England were in the midst of trying to qualify for the World Cup. Totally understandable if Carragher wasn't used to replace an injured Rio or Terry and Sol was. Besides, Carragher got into the World Cup squad, so what's his problem?


Grimes said:
i answered your point. liverpool have only been playing with two holding midfielders for the second half of last season.

Arbeloa ,Finnan, Aurelio and now Dossena all come forth and help attack. Liverpool have a great defensive base, but we are no means just defensive, we scored the most goals in all competitions last season.
Your full backs do not bomb forward and whip in crosses a la Wes Brown, Evra, Cole, Ferriera, Clichy and Cole. You couldn't name one Liverpool full-back that is more attacking than any of these plays. If these guys got forawrd Liverpool wouldn't have any issues with width. Arsenal have no true wingers but Sagna and clichy compensated. Same for Chelsea.
SKENGMAN MODE said:
your not real life... just something of the internet
5th September '08, 08:00 PM#54
GrimesSuper ModI will continue with my wicked waysiDonateJoined: January 2008Reppin: Y'all need mePosts: 39,157▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
The Messiah said:
This argument is going into minutiae and missing the overall point.

With regards to Wes Brown, Richards, Woodgate, Campbell and King - they were more than capable of getting England through that group with both Terry and Rio injured. Meaning that carrager not being in the england squad wasn't a factor at all in England getting knocked out. Deep down you know this so we can move on?
LOL.

seen. their capability is being questioned and thats the point at hand. that having carragher in england defence would of significantly improved the chances of england qualifying.
5th September '08, 08:02 PM#55
The MessiahSuper ModThe Grime Forum DoctorReppin: The EndsPosts: 19,250▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Hij said:
Now your inferring that we believe Carragher was the reason England got knocked out?

Beggars belief now mate.
The Messiah said:
Again disagree. Was Carragher ever better than Rio Ferdinand, John Terry and pre-2005 Sol Campbell? No.

Thus Carragher only needed needed to do the "Phil Neville" role of filling in when the big guys were injured. Those squad players are important people at the end of the day. Carragher was being selfish in my opinion by deciding to leave becuase he wasn't first choice CB. To be honest England are so blessed at centre-back the moment that he's not even missed - I think deep down he knows that, and it probably irritates him. At least I hope it does.
This was the response:


Grimes said:
LOL england failed to qualify from the Euro with their main defenders being constantly injured.
What does it imply given what I posted? That's what I thought...
SKENGMAN MODE said:
your not real life... just something of the internet
5th September '08, 08:02 PM#56
'nuum generalGrime Forum OGJoined: January 2006Reppin: HullPosts: 17,188▮
The Messiah said:
Tottenham had Paul Robinson in goal. How can King work with that heap of crap? Besides, King only played 5 games or something silly like that anyway. Like I said switch Reina for someone like Robinson and see how different the stats are. You can't attribute the defensive stats to any one player. If you have to do so then the only person it can be is the goalie.
Spurs concede so many due to their midfield rather than their defence/keeper due to airheads like Jenas.
The Myth
5th September '08, 08:03 PM#57
6Grime Forum EliteiDonateJoined: April 2008Posts: 11,231▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
quality said:
Carragher can kick a ball obviously, but being completely comfortable with it is another thing.
You obviously no nothing about him.

Carragher IS completely comfortable with the ball. He can pass it well, he turn oncoming strikers and find space... just go and watch him play before assuming he's one of those defenders who hoofs it out for a throw in every time it comes to him.
5th September '08, 08:04 PM#58
HijFounderGrime Forum ManagerReppin: London, United Kingdom, UPosts: 58,371▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Like i said, when is an England squad ever truly chosen on form? Campbell was still performing well at the time, had much more international experience and England were in the midst of trying to qualify for the World Cup. Totally understandable if Carragher wasn't used to replace an injured Rio or Terry and Sol was. Besides, Carragher got into the World Cup squad, so what's his problem?.

To be honest, I guess Carragher will never be recognised as the solid defend he was. Put him in a title winning side such as Chelsea or United and maybe the recognition would have been more forthcoming.

Although I guess he knows the Anfield faithful always will.

Absolute legend in Istanbul, playing through cramp, fucking battler.
Jack 1017 said:
Suarez is probably the best player in the world
5th September '08, 08:05 PM#59
HijFounderGrime Forum ManagerReppin: London, United Kingdom, UPosts: 58,371▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
The Messiah said:
Your full backs do not bomb forward and whip in crosses a la Wes Brown, Evra, Cole, Ferriera, Clichy and Cole. You couldn't name one Liverpool full-back that is more attacking than any of these plays. If these guys got forawrd Liverpool wouldn't have any issues with width. Arsenal have no true wingers but Sagna and clichy compensated. Same for Chelsea.
To be honest, I can't argue with this.

Grimes, if your honest, Dossenna has been absolutely woeful for £8 million so far.
Jack 1017 said:
Suarez is probably the best player in the world
5th September '08, 08:06 PM#60
adidasgrandadGrime Forum OGiDonateJoined: January 2008Posts: 18,968▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Hij said:
Don't chuck one at him then.

He's Scouse, He's Sound, He'll Twat You With A Pound, Carragher!
He didnt even know who threw it lol Just threw it randomly into a big crowd. Could have hit a kid.
smokey joe - "Mik looks likes a turtle"
5th September '08, 08:06 PM#61
GrimesSuper ModI will continue with my wicked waysiDonateJoined: January 2008Reppin: Y'all need mePosts: 39,157▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
defensively yes. but it terms of getting into attacking areas and contributing he has done well
5th September '08, 08:06 PM#62
The MessiahSuper ModThe Grime Forum DoctorReppin: The EndsPosts: 19,250▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Grimes said:
LOL.

seen. their capability is being questioned and thats the point at hand. that having carragher in england defence would of significantly improved the chances of england qualifying.
Oh he would have improved hteir chances, no doubt about it. But England would have qualified without him if they were managed correctly. That's the point.


6 said:
You obviously no nothing about him.

Carragher IS completely comfortable with the ball. He can pass it well, he turn oncoming strikers and find space... just go and watch him play before assuming he's one of those defenders who hoofs it out for a throw in every time it comes to him.
jCV6Verj0es
SKENGMAN MODE said:
your not real life... just something of the internet
5th September '08, 08:07 PM#63
HijFounderGrime Forum ManagerReppin: London, United Kingdom, UPosts: 58,371▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Besides, King only played 5 games or something silly like that anyway..

EXACTLY!!!!!!!

Major fucking par.
Jack 1017 said:
Suarez is probably the best player in the world
5th September '08, 08:08 PM#64
The MessiahSuper ModThe Grime Forum DoctorReppin: The EndsPosts: 19,250▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Hij said:
To be honest, I guess Carragher will never be recognised as the solid defend he was. Put him in a title winning side such as Chelsea or United and maybe the recognition would have been more forthcoming.
You mean he could have been overhyped in the way John Terry has been (in my eyes at least anyway)
SKENGMAN MODE said:
your not real life... just something of the internet
5th September '08, 08:08 PM#65
GrimesSuper ModI will continue with my wicked waysiDonateJoined: January 2008Reppin: Y'all need mePosts: 39,157▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
totenham have conceded a goal a game so far this season. with king clearly accountable for atleast one of those (against sunderland) (3 games so far).
5th September '08, 08:08 PM#66
HijFounderGrime Forum ManagerReppin: London, United Kingdom, UPosts: 58,371▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
jCV6Verj0es

That's a one off and you know it.

I thought I was a guy who argued even with only a little bit of thread left to stop me falling off a cliff, but it appears we both end up falling into the sea.
Jack 1017 said:
Suarez is probably the best player in the world
5th September '08, 08:09 PM#67
HijFounderGrime Forum ManagerReppin: London, United Kingdom, UPosts: 58,371▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
The Messiah said:
You mean he could have been overhyped in the way John Terry has been (in my eyes at least anyway)
No, he could have been given a lot more respect, this thread is evident of that.
Jack 1017 said:
Suarez is probably the best player in the world
5th September '08, 08:10 PM#68
GrimesSuper ModI will continue with my wicked waysiDonateJoined: January 2008Reppin: Y'all need mePosts: 39,157▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
The Messiah said:
Oh he would have improved hteir chances, no doubt about it. But England would have qualified without him if they were managed correctly. That's the point.
nope i disagree. Mcclaren done no different then what capello is doing now i think capello knows something about managing.


jCV6Verj0es
nope i disagree. Mcclaren done no different then what capello is doing now i think capello knows something about managing.

LOL I knew you was gonna bring up when henry or Zola bullied him.
5th September '08, 08:11 PM#69
HijFounderGrime Forum ManagerReppin: London, United Kingdom, UPosts: 58,371▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
To be perfectly frank, it was John Terry holding down the Portugal keeper that had Sol Campbells goal disallowed and knocked us out of the cup before.
Jack 1017 said:
Suarez is probably the best player in the world
5th September '08, 08:12 PM#70
The MessiahSuper ModThe Grime Forum DoctorReppin: The EndsPosts: 19,250▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Hij said:
That's a one off and you know it.

I thought I was a guy who argued even with only a little bit of thread left to stop me falling off a cliff, but it appears we both end up falling into the sea.
The fact is, that goal came to mind immediately.

I haven't said anywhere that Carragher was/is a bad player, or didn't have an outstanding season a few years back.
I've given a reasonable expanaation as to why he wasn't 3rd choice in 05.
I've said that Carragher should have realised his role in the England set up - and with that in mind acted selfishly. When did Phil Neville ever moan about not starting?

That's it really.
SKENGMAN MODE said:
your not real life... just something of the internet
5th September '08, 08:14 PM#71
The MessiahSuper ModThe Grime Forum DoctorReppin: The EndsPosts: 19,250▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Grimes said:
nope i disagree. Mcclaren done no different then what capello is doing now i think capello knows something about managing.

LOL I knew you was gonna bring up when henry or Zola bullied him.
Carragher will be playing the Henry's, Toni's, Villa's, Robinho's etc. in international football. If he gets bullied often by the very good players (I'm not saying he does, but i'm not saying he doesn't either) then he shouldn't be a first choice England centre back should he?


Hij said:
To be perfectly frank, it was John Terry holding down the Portugal keeper that had Sol Campbells goal disallowed and knocked us out of the cup before.
Irrelevant. Had nothing to do with defensive duties.
SKENGMAN MODE said:
your not real life... just something of the internet
5th September '08, 08:18 PM#72
GrimesSuper ModI will continue with my wicked waysiDonateJoined: January 2008Reppin: Y'all need mePosts: 39,157▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
The Messiah said:
Carragher will be playing the Henry's, Toni's, Villa's, Robinho's etc. in international football. If he gets bullied often by the very good players (I'm not saying he does, but i'm not saying he doesn't either) then he shouldn't be a first choice England centre back should he?



Irrelevant. Had nothing to do with defensive duties.
hmm
5th September '08, 08:18 PM#73
HijFounderGrime Forum ManagerReppin: London, United Kingdom, UPosts: 58,371▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
The Messiah said:
I've said that Carragher should have realised his role in the England set up -
Oh, his role.... LOL.

What role? you mean the role of travelling around the world, to a load of random places to park his arse on a bench or being played out of position, knowing that if anything does happen to the players that play in his position, he won't be picked to move into that slot, despite being a key player in Liverpool picking up 82 points in the 2005/2006 season, where his defence conceded 6 less than Campbell and Arsenal, and 9 less than Manchester United and Ferdinand, despite being a key player in Liverpool winning their first Champions League trophy and being crucial in stopping Chelsea breaking us down at Anfield in two semi finals in 3 years?

Despite all of that he wasn't good enough, not even for a fucking friendly? Get away.

When he could have been back in England, training, working on himself, with his team mates on winning Liverpool the league title. And as unlikely as it is for him to do that with Liverpool now, its a choice Im glad he's made.
Jack 1017 said:
Suarez is probably the best player in the world
5th September '08, 08:20 PM#74
HijFounderGrime Forum ManagerReppin: London, United Kingdom, UPosts: 58,371▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
The Messiah said:
then he shouldn't be a first choice England centre back should he?
I'm personally arguing he should have been 3rd choice.




The Messiah said:
Irrelevant. Had nothing to do with defensive duties.
Oh, and taking a penalty to be the glory guy for Chelsea, costing them the European Cup.

How many similar mistakes does he have to make before he is considered a liability under pressure?
Jack 1017 said:
Suarez is probably the best player in the world
5th September '08, 08:24 PM#75
GrimesSuper ModI will continue with my wicked waysiDonateJoined: January 2008Reppin: Y'all need mePosts: 39,157▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
My point:
Carragher is better than king
5th September '08, 08:25 PM#76
The MessiahSuper ModThe Grime Forum DoctorReppin: The EndsPosts: 19,250▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
like Rio wasn't bullied by Danny the other day

Ledley king by Drogba

Vidic by Kaka

I'm goin to ignore King for the time being but he don't play. If you had to tally such incidences for all these players who do reckon would have the highest? I know where my money would go...


Oh, his role.... LOL.You mean, travelling around the world, to a load of random places to park his arse on a bench or being played out of position, knowing that if anything does happen to the players that play in his position, he won't be picked to move into that slot, despite being a key player in Liverpool picking up 82 points in the 2005/2006 season, where his defence conceded 6 less than Campbell and Arsenal, and 9 less than Manchester United and Ferdinand, despite being a key player in Liverpool winning their first Champions League trophy and being crucial in stopping Chelsea breaking us down at Anfield in two semi finals in 3 years?

Hij said:
Despite all of that he wasn't good enough, not even for a fucking friendly?
When he could be back in England, training, working on himself, with his team mates on winning Liverpool the league title. And as unlikely as it is for him to do that with Liverpool now, its a choice Im glad his made.

Get away.

Pink = Irrelevant stats

Great post showing the lack of pride in the national shirt. Doesn't matter if he's travelling miles to not play or play out of position. you should have pride in teh fact that you are selected.

Obviously him not playing for England is of benefit to L'pool, but like I said, he showed a lack of understanding of his role and what a squad is about. Simple as.
SKENGMAN MODE said:
your not real life... just something of the internet
5th September '08, 08:26 PM#77
6Grime Forum EliteiDonateJoined: April 2008Posts: 11,231▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
jCV6Verj0es

How does Carragher slipping up one time (when he didn't even have the ball...) have anything to do with his comfort on the ball?...
5th September '08, 08:29 PM#78
The MessiahSuper ModThe Grime Forum DoctorReppin: The EndsPosts: 19,250▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
Hij said:
I'm personally arguing he should have been 3rd choice.
And I don;t think you are wrong, but I'm saying there are fair and legititamte reason why he wasn't at the time:


Hij said:
Campbell was still performing well at the time, had much more international experience and England were in the midst of trying to qualify for the World Cup.
WCQ aren't a time to try and slot someone new into the team.


Hij said:
Oh, and taking a penalty to be the glory guy for Chelsea, costing them the European Cup.

How many similar mistakes does he have to make before he is considered a liability under pressure?
He has to live with that and we get the joy of reminding him about it through chants in the stadium. But again, this point is irrelevant to defensive duties which is what this thread is all about. Terry is not there to take penalties, he's there to tackle players nad not give penalties away.
SKENGMAN MODE said:
your not real life... just something of the internet
5th September '08, 08:29 PM#79
GrimesSuper ModI will continue with my wicked waysiDonateJoined: January 2008Reppin: Y'all need mePosts: 39,157▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
The Messiah said:
I'm goin to ignore King for the time being but he don't play. If you had to tally such incidences for all these players who do reckon would have the highest? I know where my money would go...
LOL Carragher would be winning until 2005.
5th September '08, 08:30 PM#80
GrimesSuper ModI will continue with my wicked waysiDonateJoined: January 2008Reppin: Y'all need mePosts: 39,157▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮▮
I reckon Terry still

See the saved original on the Wayback Machine